Thursday, November 23, 2023

Before Herzl, There Was Pastor Russell: A Neglected Chapter of Zionism

Before Herzl, There Was Pastor Russell: A Neglected Chapter of Zionism

Years before Theodor Herzl proposed creating a Jewish state, Charles Taze Russell was traveling the world holding Jewish Mass Meetings, beginning in 1879, at which he urged Jews to find a national home in Eretz Israel  






"There are now in the world more than ten million Jews, about three-quarters of whom are in Russia, Poland, the Balkan States, and Turkey. If the movement toward Palestine should get the impulse that the Hirsch committee is able to give it, an imaginative person can conceive of the country's doubling or trebling its Jewish population before the close of our century" - Zion's Watchtower 1892, Nov. 1, p.329. 

Theodor Herzl published his pamphlet "Der Judenstaat" in 1896 and, two years later, organized the world's First Zionist Congress in Basel, Switzerland. But in fact the notion of a Jewish state in Palestine had been making the rounds in European and American Christian circles, in various forms. One of its keenest proponents was a Christian preacher and Bible scholar named Charles Taze Russell (1852-1916).

The proposition boldly put forward by Pastor Russell contrasted with the position of many Christian churches at the time, where the feeling was that God's covenant with the Jews had long since ended and they should convert to Christianity.

The prescient pastor predicted a massive exodus of Jews from Russia and Eastern Europe. Much as he predicted, by 1924 more than 3 million Jews had emigrated from Russia and Eastern Europe. Russell himself did not live long enough to see his prophecy made manifest, dying in 1916.

Russell's legacy as an enthusiastic, non-proselytizing Zionist has been acknowledged by none other than the incumbent prime minister of Israel, Benjamin Netanyahu, who said, “A recognition of Pastor Russell's important role as an early American Christian advocate of Zionism is long overdue.” The late Jeane Kirkpatrick, former the U.S. ambassador to the UN, called Russell a “neglected man and chapter in the history of Zionism.”

  • Jerusalem: The not-so-eternal capital of the Jewish people
  • Isaiah the Prophet, man or biblical myth: The archaeological evidence
  • Divers find unexpected Roman inscription from the eve of Bar-Kochba Revolt

Who was this forgotten father of Zionism, and why would he promote Zionism in the first place?

In the aftermath of civil war

In the mid-19th century, when covered wagons still rolled across the open plains carrying settlers to remote sectors of America, when vast herds of buffalo still roamed the range, Charles Taze Russell was born in Allegheny, Pennsylvania on February 16, 1852. He was the second son of Joseph L. and Ann Eliza Russell, both of Scottish-Irish descent.

Russell's mother died when he was nine years old. At 11, Charles entered a business partnership with his father, the youngster himself writing the articles of agreement under which their enterprise operated. At 15 he and his father were running a flourishing men's clothing chain with shops in Pittsburgh, Philadelphia and more.

Russell's formative years were colored by the devastating Civil War that ravaged America from 1861 to 1865, followed by an era of rapid industrialization. In 1869 the first transcontinental railway was completed. Come the the 1870's, electric light and the telephone came onto  the scene. The electric streetcar would arrive in the 1880's, and by the century's end, a few automobiles would be noisily proclaiming their presence. 

On the intellectual front, Charles Darwin's theory of evolution, described in his 1859 book "On the Origin of Species," had for the first time seriously challenged the Roman Catholic Church's version of history, giving rise to spin-off churches and creeds. 


Going back to basics

This setting of breakneck development and intellectual progress is where Russell founded the Bible Student Association, which aspired to go back to basics by studying the Bible itself.

Soon a class for systematic Bible Study was formed in Allegheny, Pennsylvania, and in 1879 Charles Taze Russell was elected its pastor. The movement founded Zion's Watch Tower, the most widely circulated magazine in the world today, according to Business Insider, with an average of 70 million copies a month in 334 languages. For comparison, National Geographic has a circulation of something over 6 million and is published in 25 different languages.

A few years later, in 1881, Russell was elected the first president of the Watchtower Society. Its purpose was to distribute his teachings in the form of tracts.

Russell was a prolific writer, and his major accomplishments include a six-volume series of systematic theology, "Studies in the Scriptures." By 1909 this series was one of most widely circulated works in the world, surpassed only by the Bible and The Chinese Almanac.

His crowning achievement at that phase was "The Photo-Drama of Creation," a ground-breaking innovation that combined sound and color in a motion picture for the first time in history. The film was, viewed by more then eight million people, an astronomical success in the terms of the times.

In 1909 Russell moved The Watch Tower Society Headquarters to 124 Columbia Heights in Brooklyn Heights. It would remain there until 2016, when Jared Kushner, son-in-law of U.S. President Donald Trump, bought the property.

Early advocate  of Zionism

On August 18, 1891, now in Jerusalem, Russell wrote to the philanthropists Baron Maurice de Hirsch and Baron Edmond de Rothschild, or as he puts it “the two leading Hebrews of the world.” No less, he put forward a practical plan for Zionism.

It  involved purchasing all government-owned land in Palestine, i.e., land not held by private owners, from the impoverished Ottoman Empire. Years later Herzl would make similar proposals.  (A copy of the letter is published in "Zion's Watchtower and Herald of Christ's Presence", December 1891, pp. 170-171.)

“As you will see from my books, we find the testimony of the prophets to be, that your nation will be greatly blessed and return to divine favor between now and the year 1915, A.D.," Russell wrote. The persecutions that Jews were suffering in Russia were "a mark of divine favor rather then the reverse," the pastor suggested - and it would only get worse because the Lord's purpose was to drive the Jews "out of all lands whither he has scattered them."



To where? To Palestine, as apparently indicated by the prophet (Jeremiah 32:37-44; 33:6-22), Russell explained. Owning not an inch of that land, he had no vested interest, the pastor elaborated, and went on: "My suggestion is that the wealthy Hebrews purchase from Turkey, at a fair valuation, all of her property interest in these lands: i.a., all of the Government lands (lands not held by private owners), under the provision that Syria and Palestine shall be constituted a FREE STATE…"

In his letter, Russell delicately gibes at alternative "Jewish homeland" ideas touted at the time in places other than Israel, though Baron de Hirsch was actually involved in resettling Jews elsewhere: "But please note, my dear Sir, that the sacred Scriptures predict the return to Palestine, and not a further wandering to the ends of the earth—to America or elsewhere. And, therefore, it is my humble opinion that Israel will find no rest for the sole of his foot until he finds the land of promise; and I pray you, therefore, not to waste your efforts in assisting emigration elsewhere, but concentrate them in the direction where God has indicated success…”

We cannot know whether he even replied to Russell, let alone be influenced by him. But a month after Russell's letter to the barons, on September 11th 1891, Baron Hirsch founded the Jewish Colonization Association to buy land, principally in North and South America but in Palestine too, where agricultural colonies could be established and resettled by Jews who were persecuted in Russia.

Meanwhile, the pastor's message did not go unnoticed in the broader Jewish communities of the United States and Europe.


Highlights from Pastor Charles Taze Russel's Photo Drama of Creation movieCredit: YouTube

Russell's Yiddish newspaper

In 1910 Pastor Russell received a letter from a committee of Jewish leaders:

"Dear Sir: Your Sympathetic interest in the Jewish people for years past has not escaped our notice. Your denunciation of the atrocities perpetrated against our race in the name of Christianity has added to our conviction that you are a sincere friend," wrote the committee members.

"Your discourse on “Jerusalem and Jewish Hopes” has struck a responsive chord in the hearts of many of our people. Still we doubted for a time if any Christian minister could really be interested in a Jew as a Jew and merely from a hope of proselyting him…You may well understand how surprised we are to find a Christian minister acknowledging that there are prophecies of the Bible still fulfilled, which belong to the Jew and not to the Christian…

"These things, Pastor Russell, have led to the formation of a Jewish Mass Meeting Committee, which by this letter, request you to give a public discourse," they concluded.

The pastor acceded and on October 9, 1910 gave a talk titled “Zionism in Prophecy” before an audience of about 4,000 Jews at the Hippodrome, New York's largest and finest auditorium at the time.

As The New York American reported on that day, “The unusual spectacle of 4,000 Hebrews enthusiastically applauding a Gentile preacher, after having listened to a sermon he addressed to them concerning their own religion…where Pastor Russell, the famous head of the Brooklyn Tabernacle conducted a most unusual service. It was not long before all reserve, and all possible doubt of Pastor Russell’s entire sincerity and friendliness were worn away. Then the mention of the name of a great leader [Herzl] who, the speaker declared, had been raised by God for the cause -- brought a burst of applause."

Russell held similar mass meetings in Chicago, Philadelphia, St. Louis, Kansas City and Cincinnati. In England he addressed 4,600 Jews in London's Royal Albert Hall, following which he appeared in Glasgow and Manchester, then gave talks in other European cities with large Jewish populations, including Vienna, Berlin, Krakow and Budapest.

Make no mistake, his speeches got a mixed reception. After Russell had left one meeting, three Jewish groups got into such a row that 46 policemen were called to disperse them. A Jewish rabbi in New York who fiercely opposed Russell influenced his associates in Austria-Hungary to resist plans for meetings addressing Jews.



However, the Herzl Year Book provides statistics of the printed preaching on the subject of Judaism and Zionism, which appeared in 107,000 copies of Anglo-Jewish newspapers and weeklies, and in 650,000 copies of the Yiddish Press. Russell even published a Yiddish-language paper of his own, Die Shtimme - "the voice".

Separate covenants

Why would a devout Christian minister invest so much in advocating the idea of a national homeland for the Jews? 

In May 26, 1911, Jacob De Haas, editor of the Boston Jewish Advocate and a personal confidant of Herzl, published an article in the Jewish Advocate praising Russell as a “Philo-semite” with no desire to convert the Jews.

But question of Russell's motivation doesn't lead to philo-Semitism necessarily:  rather it goes to the prophecies of restoration delivered to ancient Israel by prophets in the Bible  (Jeremiah 30:18; 31-8-10; Amos 9:14,15; Romans 22:25,26).

"And I will bring again the captivity of my people of Israel, and they shall build the waste cities, and inhabit them; and they shall plant vineyards, and drink the wine thereof; they shall also make gardens, and eat the fruit of them" - Amos 9:14, for example

Russell was confident that these verses would be fulfilled and that God would restore the Jews to Palestine. In November 1892 he wrote in Zion's Watch Tower: "There are now in the world more than ten million Jews, about three-quarters of whom are in Russia, Poland, the Balkan States, and Turkey. If the movement toward Palestine should get the impulse that the Hirsch committee is able to give it, an imaginative person can conceive of the country's doubling or trebling its Jewish population before the close of our century, and of its having a larger Jewish population fifty years hence than it had in ancient times, when its census ran up to three millions. Should the restoration be accomplished, all hail to the New Jerusalem!" 

He also believed that God had a separate covenant with the Jews and a different covenant with Christians, writing in the Watch Tower, in January 1909, page 28: “The more closely we investigate the New Covenant, the more we must be convinced of this fact - that it belongs to Israel alone."


These were the sentiments on which Russell's advocacy of Zionism was based. While he may not have lived to see the fulfillment of his wishes, his legacy continued.

He died in 1916. In 1925, his successor Judge Joseph F. Rutherford wrote the book "Comfort for the Jews."

Rutherford is rather more renowned for founding Jehovah's Witnesses, a religious group that emerged from Russell's Bible Student Movement.

Before Russell, no Anglo-Jewish newspapers or Yiddish press had carried articles by a Christian minister. When he died on October 31, 1916, the Herzl Year Book observed:"Russell himself, according to the testimony of the American Jewish Press from the years 1910 to 1916, maintained excellent and friendly relations with the leaders of American Jewry to his last days."


This article originally appeared in Haaretz August 22, 2018



Friday, September 29, 2023

Regarding The 1600 Furlongs of Revelation "A Suggestion" From Morton Edgar

September 25, 1946 

When studying Revelation, what did you find regarding the 1600 (or 1200) furlongs? I expect you will not take whole-heartedly to the exposition found in Vol. VII? 

The word "without the city" may mean: outside the Nominal Church, or organized religion. The horses (not horse) represent the doctrines, and the bridles the creeds. The blood represents the opposition truths, the truths of the Scriptures opposed to the false doctrines and creeds of the Nominal Church. 

This opposition was within the Church in the begining. It began outside (without) as the result of the first Ecumenical Council, held at Arles in France, in the year 314 A.D. Naturally those who persisted in proclaiming the truth (and the central truth at that time was against the Trinitarian Doctrine, for the true followers of the Lord maintained that Jesus Christ is not equal to the Father, but that the Father is greater than Jesus, as our Lord himself proclaimed) were cast out of the Nominal Church. And they have been out ever since, right up to 1914 when the breaking up of the nations began, and the breaking up of the Nominal Church too. Things are not as they were, since 1914; and they shall never return to what they were, as all know, - that is, all who really know and understand. From 314 A.D. to 1914 A.D. is 1600 years. In this instance a furlong represents a year (in the corroborative Great Pyramid a year is represented by a measured length of an inch, and a cubit, etc. 

The above is a suggestion, - and I would like you to think it over and let me know your opinion in due course. 

 The 1200 furlongs spoken of in Vol. VII does not appear to be correct; and you will have noted that there is no explanatory comment regarding the 1200 as opposed to the 1600 in the volume.) The Sinaitic, though the olderst MSS, is not necessarily always correct.

But I must close for this time; and I hope to hear from you again. 

With much love in the Lord to you both, 

from Sister Minna and myself, 

Your loving brother 

Morton Edgar

from a 17 page collection of letters called "edgars.pdf" 

email zidkenu@protonmail.com for a copy.

Tuesday, September 26, 2023

Comparing The Language of the Trumpets and Bowls of Revelation

Comparing the language of the trumpets and bowls of Revelation
Trumpets Bowls
Rev. 8:6 And the seven messengers, those having the seven trumpets, prepared themselves, so that they might sound. Rev. 16:1 And I heard a great voice out of the temple saying to the seven angels, Go your ways, and pour out the vials of the wrath of God upon the earth.
Rev. 8:7 And the first sounded, and was hail and fire having been mingled with blood, and they were cast into the earth; and the third of the earth was burnt up, and the third of the trees was burnt up, and all grass green was burnt up. Rev. 16:2 And the first went, and poured out his vial upon the earth; and there fell a noisome and grievous sore upon the men which had the mark of the beast, and upon them which worshipped his image.
Rev. 8:8 And the second messenger sounded, and as it were a mountain great with fire burning was cast into the sea; and became the third of the sea, blood; 9 and died the third of the creatures of the in the sea, things having souls; and the third of the ships was destroyed. Rev. 16:3 And the second angel poured out his vial upon the sea; and it became as the blood of a dead man; and every living soul died in the sea.
Rev. 8:10 And the third messenger sounded, and fell from the heaven a star great burning like a lamp, and it fell on the third of the rivers, and on the fountains of the waters. 11 And the name of the star is called the Wormwood; and became the third of the waters into wormwood; and many of the men died of the waters, because they were made bitter. Rev. 16:4 And the third angel poured out his vial upon the rivers and fountains of waters; and they became blood. 5 And I heard the angel of the waters say, Thou art righteous, O Lord, which art, and wast, the Holy One, because thou hast judged thus. 6 For they have shed the blood of saints and prophets, and thou hast given them blood to drink; for they are worthy. 7 And I heard the altar say, Even so, Lord God Almighty, true and righteous are thy judgments.
Rev. 8:12 And the fourth messenger sounded, and was smitten the third of the sun and the third of the moon and the third of the stars, so that might be darkened the third of them, and the day not might shine the third of herself, and the night in like manner. Rev. 16:8 And the fourth angel poured out his vial upon the sun; and power was given unto him to scorch men with fire. 9 And men were scorched with great heat, and blasphemed the name of God, which hath power over these plagues: and they repented not to give him glory.
Rev. 9:

1 And the fifth messenger sounded, and I saw a star from the heaven having fallen to the earth, and was given to him the key of the pit of the deep; 2 and he opened the pit of the deep. And went up a smoke out of the pit as a smoke of a furnace great, and was darkened the sun and the air by the smoke of the pit. 3 And out of the smoke went out locusts into the earth, and was given them authority as having authority the scorpions of the earth; 4 and it was said to them, that not they should injure the grass of the earth, nor any green thing, nor any tree, if not the men those who not have the seal of the God on the foreheads of themselves; 5 and it was given to them that not they might kill them, but that they might torment months five; and the torment of them as a torment of a scorpion, when it may strike a man. 6 And in the days those shall seek the men the death, and not not shall find him; and they shall desire to die, and shall flee away from them the death. ...

12 The woe the one passed away; lo, comes more two woes after these.

Rev. 16:10 And the fifth angel poured out his vial upon the seat of the beast; and his kingdom was full of darkness; and they gnawed their tongues for pain, 11 And blasphemed the God of heaven because of their pains and their sores, and repented not of their works.
Rev. 9:
13
 And the sixth messenger sounded, and I heard voice one from the four horns of the altar of the golden of that in presence of the God, 14 saying to the sixth messenger the one having the trumpet: Loose thou the four messengers those having been bound by the river the great Euphrates. 15 And were loosed the four messengers those having been prepared for the hour and a day and a month and a year, so that they should kill the third of the men.

...
21 and not reformed from the murders of themselves, nor from the sorceries of themselves, nor from the fornication of themselves, nor from the thefts of themselves. [Compare Rev. 16:10]
Rev. 16:12 And the sixth angel poured out his vial upon the great river Euphrates; and the water thereof was dried up, that the way of the kings of the east might be prepared.
Rev. 9:

15 And the seventh messenger sounded, and were voices great in the heaven, saying: Became the kingdom of the world, of the Lord of us and of the Anointed of him, and he will reign for the age of the ages.

16 And the twenty-four elders those in presence of the God sitting on the thrones of themselves, fell on the faces of themselves, and worshipped the God, 17 saying: We give thanks to thee, O Lord the God the almighty, the one existing and who was, because thou hast taken the power of thee the great, and reigned. 18 And the nations were angry, and came the wrath of thee, and the season of the dead ones, to be judged and to give the reward to the bond-servants of thee the prophets and to the holy ones and to those fearing the name of thee the small ones and the great ones, and to destroy those destroying the earth.

19 And was opened the temple of the God in the heaven, and was seen the ark of the covenant of the Lord in the temple of him; and were lightnings and voices and thunders and an earthquake and hail great.

Rev. 16:17 And the seventh angel poured out his vial into the air; and there came a great voice out of the temple of heaven, , saying, It is done. 18 And there were voices, and thunders, and lightnings; and there was a great earthquake, such as was not since men were upon the earth, so mighty an earthquake, and so great. 19 And the great city was divided into three parts, and the city of the nations fell: and great Babylon came in remembrance before God, to give unto her the cup of the wine of the fierceness of his wrath. 20 And every island fled away, and the mountains were not found. 21 And there fell upon men a great hail out of heaven, every stone about the weight of a talent: and men blasphemed God because of the plague of the hail; for the plague thereof was exceeding great.
Commentary: The above side by side comparison has no commentary from me, I am just looking at it this way for my own study. Others may enjoy so I publish it here with just one comment from me on the 7th: While there are some exact linguistic matches, it's the subject matter that matters most as both passages portray the same overall narrative of a time when God takes control of earth's affairs and gives out rewards and punishments. rcb



Sunday, September 24, 2023

Revelation Table: The Seven Stages, 7 Seals, 7 Trumpets, 7 Bowls & 7 Parables of Our Lord

Here's a table showing the historical nature of the book of Revelation that I've been putting together for my own personal study. It is still currently under construction. This is not the only such chart in existence and it is far from perfect. There is much not covered under these topics from the book of Revelation. I am not saying that there are not dual or multiple fulfillments. I am not saying that this is the exact fulfillment for all the brethren for all time. I'm studying to find the answers that are biblical, historical and satisfying to sanctified reason. It's a study, not a conclusion. I'm sharing it so others might hopefully derive some benefit from it and perhaps share back with improvements so feel free to offer suggestions.

While I am not saying each chronological period is exact, I'm also not saying that they are not - possibly - exact chronological matches when it comes to the seven stages, seals, trumpets and parables of our Lord. I'll be adding more as we go along including more web links. updated as a time allows and as Revelation unfolds... D.v...

THE SEVEN SEALS of REVELATION


Revelation 5
1 And I saw, upon the right hand of him that was sitting upon the throne, a scroll; written within, and on the back, sealed up with seven seals.

2 And I saw a mighty messenger, proclaiming with a loud voice-Who is worthy to open the scroll, and to unloose the seals thereof?

3 And, no one, was able, in heaven, or on earth, or under the earth, to open the scroll, or, to look thereon.

4 And, I, began to weep much, because, no one, worthy, was found, to open the scroll, or, to look thereon.

5 And, one of the elders, saith unto me-Do not weep! Lo! the lion that is of the tribe of Judah, the root of David, hath overcome, to open the scroll and the seven seals thereof.


“Then came the opening of the seals: the disclosing of one after another of the
various features connected with the divine purpose. Each seal as it was loosed permitted
the scroll as a whole to open a little wider, and a little wider, thus permitting “the mystery
of God” to be a little more clearly discerned. And so God’s people down through this
“secret of the Lord;” — the divine plan. But not until the last seal was broken, did the
scroll fly wide open, permitting the “mystery of God” to be fully disclosed; as it is written:
“In the days of the voice of the seventh angel, when he shall begin to sound, the mystery of
God should be finished, as he hath declared to his servants the prophets.” — Rev. 5:1; 10:7.
R2209:1

Verse 1 the "scroll" is God's "Divine Plan of the Ages" sealed within the Bible.

In Rev. 5:1 God’s Word is represented by a book (scroll), written on the inside and outside and sealed with seven seals.  The things written on the outside represent the easy and simple things of the Bible, like histories, most of its precepts and exhortations and some of its doctrine, while those written on the inside sealed by seven seals represent the secret features of the Bible, none of which can be understood until in due time Jesus opens the secreting seals and expounds the thing therein to the elect people of God (Rev. 5:9).

The scroll is a forceful representation of the Divine Plan originally existing only in the mind of God, and which could not be made known to men until some one was found worthy to open the seals and display it to view.  But “no one in heaven nor in earth was able to open the scroll, neither to look thereon,” until one came whom the Revelator describes as “The lion [strong one] of the Tribe of Judah, the root of David,” of whom the testimony is given - “Thou art worthy to take the scroll and to open the seals thereof, for thou wast slain and has redeemed to God by the blood out of every kindred, and tongue, and people, and nation; and hast made them unto our God a kingdom and priesthood; and they shall reign on the earth.” (Rev.5:1-5,9,10) "The Divine Scroll" Epiphany Bible Students

THE SEVEN STAGES
of the CHURCH

Ephesus
 
29 AD to 69 AD

Smyrna
  69 AD to 313 AD

Pergamos
313 AD to 799 AD

Thyatira
799 AD to 1309 AD

Sardis
1309 AD to 1479 AD

Philadelphia
1479 AD to 1874 AD

Laodicea
1874 AD to ...

Revelation 1:4 John to the seven churches that are in Asia: Grace to you and peace, from him who is and who was and who is to come; and from the seven Spirits that are before his throne; 5 and from Jesus Christ, who is the faithful witness, the firstborn of the dead, and the ruler of the kings of the earth.

 20 the mystery of the seven stars which thou sawest in my right hand, and the seven golden candlesticks. The seven stars are the angels of the seven churches: and the seven candlesticks are seven churches.

JESUS CHRIST — THE FIRST AND THE LAST
REVELATION 1:1-8, 17-20 THE MESSAGE OF THE RISEN CHRIST — THE APOSTLE JOHN REPRESENTATIVE OF
THE FEET-MEMBERS OF THE BODY OF CHRIST — IN A TRANCE HE SAW A SERIES OF VISIONS OF THE
LEADING EVENTS OF THE GOSPEL AGE, THE SEVEN STAGES OF THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE GOSPEL
CHURCH AND THE SETTING UP OF THE MESSIANIC KINGDOM — A SYMBOLICAL PICTURE OF OUR
GLORIFIED LORD — THE WORD LIKENED TO A TWO-EDGED SWORD.
“It will be noticed that the messages to the various
Churches are addressed to these stars, messengers, angels,
as though our Lord would have us understand that the appropriate
message for each appropriate epoch in the
Church's experience would be sent by the Lord through a
particular star, or messenger, whom He would especially
commission as His representative. Our Lord Himself is
represented by the great light of the sun; and His special
messengers in the Church throughout the entire period of
the Gospel Age are consistently enough represented as stars.

November 15, 1916 Tower R5991-5992

The Bible is it's own interpreter and Jesus gives us the answer key showing us the symbolic nature of this book. Jesus is clearly identified as the first one who died and lived again.

His message is to the seven churches of John's day and given through the "star members" of each of the 7 stages or time periods of our 2000 years of church history. rcb
THE SEVEN TRUMPETS


Rev. 8:2 And I saw the seven messengers which, before God, do stand; and there were given unto them seven trumpets...

6 And, the seven messengers who had the seven trumpets, prepared themselves, that they might sound."

"...we, in common with almost all expositors, recognize that the seven trumpets of Revelation are symbolical and not literal – indeed that this entire book is a book of symbols, and that so far it has been symbolically fulfilled. Christian people in general understand that five of these trumpets have already "sounded" and are in the past; – we would say six. It is admitted that those that have already "sounded" have not been literal blasts of a bugle on the air, but divine decrees and their fulfilments; and we esteem that it is reasonable to expect that the seventh trumpet will be similar in this respect to the preceding six."

Z1902APR.asp#Z117:3

"In Num. 10:8 it is stated that “the sons of Aaron, the priests, shall blow with the trumpets”; and it is worthy of note that in each of the seven epochs of the Gospel‑Age Church it was the priests ‑ the leaders in the Church, the Star Members – who began to blow the trumpets. In the first epoch (the church of Ephesus) it was the Lord and the Apostles, and they were quickly joined by the lesser lights in the Church as they embarked on their march toward the Heavenly Canaan. And this same condition prevailed with each Star Member during the Age. When Luther began to trumpet “Justification by faith” (early in the Philadelphia ‑ sixth ‑ epoch), he was soon joined by many capable brethren." epiphany bible students
/the-gospel-age-trumpets

"Jesus is the lion of Judah, also the lamb who does the unsealing. The Bible is being unsealed. Jesus gradually does this through 7 stages of church history using his most loyal followers, many who are the blowers of the seven trumpets and not limited to seven, but with seven main characters and an "eighth principal man", the key figure of which is also the seventh angel who pours out the vials or bowls that unleash the plagues upon the erroneous Babylon system, and thereby begin to reverse the curse. This way over time, Jesus has successfully routed the enemy who is Satan." rcb

THE TRUMPETS
Each of these appears to coincide in its period with the corresponding “seal” period and
church epoch of the preceding chapters. The last three of these periods introduced by the
sounding — or beginning to sound — of the fifth, sixth, and seventh trumpets are
associated with, or bring, the three “woes” (Rev. 8:13). Rev. 9:12; 11:14 indicate that they
do not overlap. "Notes on the Book of Revelation" Ludlow Loomis
THE SEVEN BOWLS of WRATH


Rev. 16:1 And I heard a voice great out of the temple, saying to the seven messengers: Go you forth and do you pour out the seven bowls of the wrath of the God into the earth.

For a good overall summary of the plagues we recommend R497 "The Seven Last Plagues"

We use Wilson's Emphatic Diaglott translation in this column. We believe "Studies in the Scriptures" by Charles Taze Russell constituted the vials of Revelation.

Note on Time: These "bowls" or "vials" are not poured out until the 7th seal chronologically speaking. However each plague once delivered during that later time starting in 1874 would begin it's work of destruction of the false system, to reverse the effects of each of the original errors introduced during each successive stage of Church history. 

We place the "bowls" in a parallel column here, even though they were not poured out chronologically at the same time as the seals, stages, trumpets and parables of our Lord were occurring. Only in their effects against the original adverse conditions described by our Lord for each separate Church period are we making the comparison, again however not a chronological comparison which the other columns do show. rcb

The six volumes of the Studies in the Scriptures were published consecutively: The Divine Plan of the Ages, 1886; The Time is at Hand, 1889; Thy Kingdom Come, 1891; The Battle of Armageddon, 1897; The Atonement Between God and Man, 1899; and The New Creation, 1900. These volumes are six of the seven vials of Revelation 16. The seventh volume – The Finished Mystery – was published after Pastor Russell’s death. This Seventh Volume contains many quotations from Pastor Russell, but it also includes many other writings, mostly by two persons, which contain much error. While it is the Seventh Volume that is the seventh vial of Revelation 16, it is in vile condition. The Society excommunicated brethren who refused to accept the errors in that book, but later commanded their devotees not to read it. The Society has written another book also named The Finished Mystery. It may be this book is forbidden to be read by their devotees now. No. 437 "A Prophet Unto The Nations" Epiphany Bible Students
THE SEVEN PARABLES OF OUR LORD


Matt 13:1 "On that day, Jesus, going out of the house, was sitting near the sea:

2 and there were gathered unto him, large multitudes, so that, he, into a boat, entered, and was sitting, and, all the multitude, on the beach was standing.

 3 And he spake unto them many things, in parables, saying: Lo! the sower went forth to sow..."


In parables – Really word-pictures of the Kingdom. No one of these parables represents the complete view of the subject, but merely one phase of it. R2633:3

Giving prophetically the Church's experiences from various standpoints – from the time the work of selection began until the time when that work will be completed. R2276:3

Parables which illustrate truths can only be seen as illustrations as the truths they illustrate become manifest. R1742:4

These parables, seven in all, refer not to the non-professing world, but to two classes in the Church. R580:3, 263:6


Each of our Lord's parables are predictions that match the seven seals and stages of the Church. See "The Parables of Our Lord" P.L. Read 1918  rcb

In the Paul Mezera book "The Divine Plan and It's Chronology" which confirms Pastor Russell's chronology, there are charts and timelines made of circles that ultimately make up the "eyes" and "wings" depicted in divine symbolism. We point to this work as further corroboration that we are looking at several distinct periods of Bible chronology. See Rev. 4:8 rcb

First Seal

White Horse

Rev. 6:1 And I saw, when the Lamb opened one of the seven seals, and I heard one of the four living creatures saying, as with a voice of thunder-Go! [Rotherham]

2 
 And I saw, and lo a horse white, and the one sitting on him having a bow; and was given to him a crown, and he came out conquering, and that he might conquer.


white horse= pure doctrine
"the faith once delivered to the saints" Jude 1:3

"given to him"
  • bow
  • crown
  • conquering
  • "and to conquer"
Horse = doctrine
White = pure

The White Horse scene is the time period of Jesus and the Apostles during the first advent. These are the rider, who "GO" on their mission - the gradual unsealing of the Bible...

The 24 elders represent the Bible while the voices from the throne represent differing aspects of God's divine character attributes of Justice, Love, Wisdom and Power.


Notes: Rotherham says "GO" not "COME" as though the voice is NOT telling John to "look" or "come and see" but rather the voice, which always represents an aspect of God's character, is the one ordering the horse and/ or it's rider to "GO"...

The message did it's "conquering" by christianity becoming a popular faith in the first century, then His long career of conquering would continue thru the acts of his disciples and He will "conquer" still more at His promised second advent during the seventh or Laodicean period.

Note: While not wanting to create a document of confusion with too many differing viewpoints, some comments deserve mentioning where the Truth is not absolutely clear, this one from Bro. Loomis suggesting the rider is the Nicolatianes deserves mentioning. As to whether or not it effects any ultimate conclusions remains to be seen.
rcb

"The conqueror on the first horse (Rev. 6:1, 2), to whom a crown was given before he
conquered, could not represent the overcomers such as those in Rev. 2:10, nor their Lord,
whose kingdom was not of this world. (John 18:36) He seems rather to be a counterfeit of
the riders in Psalm 45:3-5, Rev. 19:11, who do represent our Lord. We have thus a picture
rather of the Nicolaitans — conquerors of the people. (Rev. 2:6, compare 1 Cor. 4:8; 1 Peter
5:3; Acts 20:29, 30) Ludlow Loomis "Notes on The Book of Revelation"




1st Stage

Ephesus

  29 AD to 69 AD

First Messenger "Stars"

  1. Simon Peter,
  2. James (son of Zebedee),
  3. John, (brother of James)
  4. Andrew,
  5. Philip,
  6. Bartholomew /Nathanael,
  7. Matthew,
  8. Thomas,
  9. James (son of Alpheus),
  10. Thaddeus (Jude of James)
  11. Simon the Caananite
  12. Paul
Rev. 2: 1 Unto the messenger of the assembly, in Ephesus, write:-These things, saith he that holdeth the seven stars in his right hand, he that walketh in the midst of the seven lamps of gold:

2 I know thy works, and thy toil, and endurance, and that thou canst not bear bad men, and thou hast tried them who were affirming themselves to be apostles, and they were not, and hast found them false;

3 And thou hast, endurance, and hast borne for the sake of my name, and hast not grown weary.

4 Nevertheless, I have against thee, that, thy first love, thou hast left.

5 Remember, therefore, whence thou hast fallen, and repent, and do, thy first works; otherwise, I come unto thee, and will remove thy lamp out of its place, except thou repent.

6 But, this, thou hast, that thou hatest the works of the Nicolaitanes, which, I also, hate.

7 He that hath an ear, let him hear what, the Spirit, is saying unto the assemblies. Unto him that overcometh -I will give, unto him, to eat of the tree of life, which is in the paradise of God.

THE CONGREGATION IN EPHESUS – (Ephesus meaning "first, desirable" – a fitting name for this epoch), this first era being from 29 to 69 AD, with St. Paul as the Principal Man, the "angel" or "star" including all twelve of the Apostles as explained above. It should be noted, too, that although this epoch embraced forty years, the twelve stars officiated in the "church which is His body" for only 36½ years. J Hoefle "The Seven Stars"

As is often said, the Christian church is like a boat at sea, fine until the "Sea" class gets in the boat. This is the time when false Christian leaders came in. Paul said "the mystery of iniquity doth already work." 2 Thess 2:7
"Nicolatians" [a root word is "Nike"] = power graspers, those who wish to become leaders. They illicitly "lord it over" the Lord's true people. rcb
1st Trumpet

Rev. 8: 7 And, the first, sounded; and there came to be hail and fire mingled with blood, and it was cast unto the earth; and, the third of the earth, was burned up, and, the third of the trees, was burned up, and, all green herbage, was burned up.

"...the first three trumpets are called the woe trumpets." R3992:4

The events under the first six trumpets refer to humanity's doings, while the seventh refers specially to the Lord's work, and covers the "Day of the Lord." (1 Thes. 5:2) B148

"The first sounded" The trumpet is the first Gospel message given by Jesus and the Apostles to the world. John 3:16
"Hail"=Great Truths
destructive to the social order. "Fire"=Destruction, however in this case it could mean the holy spirit, in which case
"mingled with blood" is symbolic for the message of the Ransom sacrifice of our Lord and the consecration of His followers even unto death, the "blood" as a symbol for life offered through the Ransom of Christ Jesus given sacrificially as our Passover lamb, also a symbol of sacrificial death by consecration or actual sacrifice through martyrdom.
The message "cast unto the earth" = the effect it had on society. The phrase "mingled with blood" may also mean loss of national vitality as the Roman government was threatened by the new Christianity then rising.

see Louisville New Albany Revelation Notes rcb

The result of this first trumpet message of Jesus and the Apostles was to divide the known world. Jesus poured scriptures on the heads of the Pharisees in a symbolic "hail" and the "fire" destroyed national Jewish polity.
This was "mingled with blood" when many Jews lost their lives under Roman rule in AD 70.

"third of the earth" = one of the three sections of society: Christian, Roman and Jewish society which is the third of the earth that "burned up" at the end of Jewish national polity.
 
"Trees" are deeply rooted people of faith - the consecrated. It may be a reference to the Jews.

"All green herbage" may refer to the new converts who abandoned their faith, a class inferred or indicated in the parable of those who grew on rocky ground and were choked by thorns. In our Parables column to the right
you can observe how closely our trumpet picture matches the first parable with damage to the "trees" and "green herbage" after what had been planted by Jesus as the Sower. rcb.]
1st Bowl of Wrath

Rev. 16:1 And I heard a voice great out of the temple, saying to the seven messengers: Go you forth and do you pour out the seven bowls of the wrath of the God into the earth.

2 And went forth the first, and poured out the bowl of himself on the land; and was an ulcer bad and evil on the men those having the mark of the wild-beast, and those doing reverence of the image of him. [diaglott]


The first bowl is the first volume of "Studies in the Scriptures" by Charles Taze Russell. rcb

“And the first went, and poured out his bowl on the earth (organized Society), and there came an evil and malignant ulcer on those men having the mark of the beast, and on those worshiping his image.” Volume One was published in 1886, and truly it proved to be a “malignant ulcer” to antitypical Saul and his henchmen; it was a “hot penny”: they could not hold it, and they were afraid to drop it. The stewardship doctrine of Restitution, with which Volume One is replete, made material for a “plan of the ages,” the likes of which had not been known since the days of the Apostles; and it placed Restitution and eternal torment at opposite ends of the measure. It did indeed “spoil the vines” for many a hell‑fire evangelist! Also, Chapter 14 – The Kingdom of God – made a shambles of the teaching that we now have Christendom – Christ’s Kingdom; and it showed the present order to be a far, far cry from “Thy will be done on earth.” Our Lord’s Return, The Permission of Evil, The Day of Judgment, etc., etc., all combined to make this “bowl” a “malignant ulcer” – “a savor of death unto death” to many members of antitypical Saul.

This is pointedly typified in Ex. 4:9: “The water which thou takest out of the river shall become blood upon the dry land.” “The water” in this text is the Truth as contained in the Bible – so excellently presented in Volume One – The Divine Plan of the Ages. The “dry land” typified the withered and sere condition of society as it existed at the time of the book’s appearance. And the “blood” represented the faulty reasoning of Christendom’s religious leaders, who branded the book as error – bloody, repulsive, abhorrent, death‑dealing – whereas, it actually contained the water of life uplifting, life‑giving, to all who were “of the Truth.” It should be noted that at that time many preachers were describing the animal sacrifices of the Law as bloody and barbaric – because they could not see the grand antitype of the “better sacrifices” (Heb. 9:23) that were offered during this Gospel Age by “the Church which is His Body.” (Eph. 1: 22,23)  No. 351 "In Memoriam" Epiphany Bible Students

When we
compare the results of the bowls with the conditions described by our Lord plaguing each church period we see certain similarities. The first stage saw bad men taking leadership. Those following them had "the mark of the beast" already in the Apostles day. It is association with and support for the false religious system that would grow into the Papacy.

"Thou gavest them blood to drink" is an apt punishment for those false Christians of the "sea" class supporting those seeking leadership as Nicolatians. The first volume "The Divine Plan of the Ages" was truly an ulcer for those serving their images as they could not refute Pastor Russell. rcb

1st PARABLE

The Sower

Matt 13:
3 
 And he spake unto them many things, in parables, saying: Lo! the sower went forth to sow,-

4 
 and, as he sowed, some, indeed, fell by the pathway, and, the birds, came, and devoured it;

5 
 And, some, fell on the rocky places, where it had not much earth,-and, straightway, it sprang up, because if had no depth of earth;

6 
 and, the sun arising, it was scorched, and, because it had no root, it withered away;

7 
 And, some, fell upon the thorns, and the thorns came up, and choked it;

8 
 But, some, fell upon the good ground, and did yield fruit,-this, indeed a hundred fold, and, that, sixty, and, the other, thirty.

9 
 He that hath ears, let him hear.


GOOD SEED FOR GOOD GROUND

FROM a boat our Lord taught a most wonderful lesson respecting the method used by the Almighty in the selection of the "little flock," whom he invites to be members with Christ Jesus in the administration of his Millennial Kingdom. The Kingdom message or invitation is the "seed" which is under consideration in the above parable, which, under favorable conditions, germinates and brings forth the required fruitage of character-development. Our Lord was the great Sower of this good seed of the Kingdom, and after him came the Apostles. Since then he has used all of his faithful people more or less in this seed-sowing.
The fact that most of the "seed" of the Divine message seems wasted is no proof that the message is not good and desirable. This parable shows that the real fault lies in the soil – in the heart. If all hearts were right the message or seed would bring forth much fruit everywhere.


This matches the conditions of the first stage and the first seal as Jesus and the Apostles supplied the good seed of the Word, as Jesus interprets this by giving a class on the symbolism. Here worldly people are those who lack character or depth to grow roots of faith. "Thorns" are earthly cares that got in the way of the message. "Birds" can be people or fallen angels who take away the message with erroneous attacks on the Truth. Those of better character are "on good ground" and were more productive. We suggest the "hundred fold" increase is spirit birth to the divine nature, 100 being a divine number, 60 standing for the Great Company class (Rev. 7:14) and 30 indicating the Youthful Worthies. We note how in the first trumpet the damage is to the "trees" and "green herbage" which may refer to Christians both established and new, grown up by the seeds of faith in Christ dispensed in the first century and as the parable of the sower details. rcb


2nd SEAL

Red Horse

Rev. 6:3 And, when he opened the second seal, I heard the second living creature, saying-Go! 4 And there went forth another, a red horse,-and, unto him that was sitting thereon, it was given, unto him, to take away peace from the earth, and that, one another, they should slay; and there was given unto him a great sword. [Rotherham]

Red Horse= Doctrine of the Ransom

"One sitting on him" = the star members including Apostle John as the principal star.

"was given him"

  • "to take peace from the earth" = the new faith created social instability
  • "kill each other"  the new faith created spiritual animosities.
  • "given him a great sword" the sword of Truth this was the time of compiling the Word of God. rcb Matthew 10:34 "Think not that I came to send peace on the earth: I came not to send peace, but a sword. 35 For I came to set a man at variance against his father, and the daughter against her mother, and the daughter in law against her mother in law: 36 and a man's foes'shall be they of his own household."

This was the most violent time under pagan Rome when Titus destroyed the temple. Although commentaries don't mention it pagan Rome persecuted the Jews to near annihilation. There were other Masada's that were reported to have occurred, fulfilling the red horse "kill each other" as regarded the Jews. Spiritually it was fulfilled as well, with the advent of controversialism and rampant anathemas and excommunications, thus fulfilling the "kill each other", the "sword" being the then known Word of God. Certainly there was no peace for Jewish society, and Jesus words can equally be applied to them as well as Christian society, which was under persecution equally during this inhospitable period of pagan rule.

The beginning of the rule of cardinals and bishops makes red and apt choice for their attire later in Catholicism. But here, the very existence of this new religion took peace from the societal earth, forcing the persecution which only failed to repress the new faith, hence the next stage of cooperation of Church and state.  The great sword strictly speaking can be interpreted as the next mouthpiece of the Word of God, since the church of this dark period was still the only source of gospel light to be found, and that only among the saintly few. rcb

See the following article refuting replacement theology:
https://ffoz.org/messiah/articles/the-synagogue-of-satan

Again when we are not certain we are open to other views on who the riders are on these horses.  Bro. Bob Jones sent us his large Revelation study which says:
Red Horse=Doctrine tainted with error="though thy sins be as scarlet..." "Revelation Decoded and Explained"

 


2nd Stage

Smyrna

  69 AD to 313 AD

Second Messenger "Stars"
  1. John
  2. Polycarp
  3. Iraneus
  4. Tertulian
Rev. 2: 8 And, unto the messenger of the assembly, in Smyrna, write:-These things, saith the first and the last, who became dead, and lived:

9 I know thy tribulation, and destitution, nevertheless, thou art, rich, and the profane speech from among them who affirm that they themselves are, Jews, and they are not, but a synagogue of Satan.

 10 Do not fear the things which thou art about to suffer. Lo! the adversary is about to cast some of you into prison, that ye may be tried, and may have tribulation ten days. Become thou faithful until death, and I will give thee the crown of life.

11 He that hath an ear, let him hear what, the Spirit, is saying unto the assemblies. He that overcometh, shall in nowise be injured by reason of the second death.

THE CONGREGATION IN SMYRNA – (Smyrna meaning "bitter," in allusion to the bitter and excruciating persecutions of the Pagan Roman Empire into the early part of the fourth century) continued from 69 to 313, the Principal Man being St. John. Here it is well to remember that John is the only one of the "stars" who was a "star" in two different epochs of the Gospel-Age Church, although he was the "principal man" in the second epoch only. He is presumed to have lived until about 100 AD...
J Hoefle "The Seven Stars"

The Lord Jesus is here in the book of Revelation addressing the second phase, the Smyrna phase, of the Church. He tells the brethren that the Roman empire, which He here calls the devil, would cast some of them into prison – would greatly restrain them in their work and persecute them most fiendishly and most outrageously; for the Smyrna Church and the Philadelphia Church were the two most persecuted by violence of any of the seven churches of the Gospel Age. Their tribulation of ten symbolic days was especially the ten years’ persecution they endured under Diocletian. The Lord exhorted them to be faithful unto death in spite of those terrible persecutions and He would give them a crown of life – immortality, the Divine nature. J Hoefle The Kingdom of God - part 1

This Babylonish union incited the leaders in civil and religious position to anni­hilate any leaders that might arise to oppose this contagion. Previous to 313 AD the Roman government had acted individually to rid itself of the Christians, the last pro­nounced effort of its kind being under Emperor Diocletian from 303 to 313 – the final years of the Smyrna period of the church. Smyrna means ‘bitter,’ and it fittingly de­scribes the experiences of the church during that time. “The devil shall cast some of you into prison... and ye shall have tribulation ten (symbolic) days” (Rev. 2:10) – ten literal years from 303 to 313. J Hoefle A Magnificent Type

2nd Trumpet

Rev. 8:8 And, the second messenger, sounded; and, as it were a great mountain burning with fire, was cast into the sea; and the third of the sea became blood,

9 and the third of the creatures which were in the sea, which had life, died, the third of the ships, was destroyed.


"mountain" = government the government of pagan Rome fell in a time of the restless "sea" a time of great social unrest saw the end of pagan Rome, the "third" that is effected. In the first stage we saw the Jewish "third" effected. The world was in three segments - Roman "Christian", Jews and Heathen. Here the Jewish third is decimated during this time period. rcb

Rev. 8:8, 9 pictures the result of the missionary effort begun during the second, or pagan, persecution period of the church. Compare B285. As a result of the missionary efforts begun then, the barbarians were converted to at least a nominal form of Christianity. Since waters
would not burn, this death to their former condition is shown by blood--shed blood being symbolic of death" Ludlow Loomis
2nd Bowl of Wrath

Rev. 16: 3 And the second messenger poured out the bowl of himself into the sea; and it became blood as of a dead one, and every soul of life died in the sea.


The second “bowl,” “The Time is at Hand,” made its appearance in 1889...And the time features were indeed a powerful refutation of those who were loudly proclaiming “no man knoweth the day nor the hour” and those who were lustily singing, “When my work on earth is ended, and time shall Be no more.” The second “bowl” demonstrated the correct translation of Rev. 10:6 to be, “The time shall be no longer delayed”; that is, the “time is at hand” for God, through the Christ, to carry out His promise of Restitution – that time had arrived for the Blessing of all the families of the earth. No. 351 "In Memoriam" Epiphany Bible Students

The second bowl is the book "The Time is at Hand" volume two of Studies in the Scriptures by Pastor Russell. This book was published during the time just after the close of the general gospel age call for high calling purposes, thus ending the spiritual hopes of the "sea" class - the nominal class of Christians at that time. rcb

Here we see again the similar language used in both the bowls and the trumpets, for when the trumpets originally sounded a third or section of population was dramatically effected. In the pouring out of the bowl we see the reciprocation upon the illicit church state system and it's die hard followers. rcb


2nd PARABLE

The Tares

Matthew 13:24 Another parable, put he before them, saying-The kingdom of the heavens hath become like a man sowing good seed in his field;

25 
 and, while men were sleeping, his enemy came, and sowed over darnel, in among the wheat,-and away he went.

26 
 And, when the blade shot up, and brought forth, fruit, then, appeared, the darnel also.

27 
 And the servants of the householder, coming near, said to him,-Sir! was it not, good seed, thou didst sow in thy field? Whence then hath it, darnel?

28 
 And he said unto them-An enemy, hath, done this. And they say, unto him-Wilt thou, then, that we go and collect it?

29 
 And, he, saith-Nay! lest, at any time, while collecting the darnel, ye uproot, along with it, the wheat:

30 
 Suffer both to grow together until the harvest, and at, harvest time, I will say unto the reapers,- Collect ye first, the darnel, and bind it into bundles, with a view to the burning it up; but, the wheat, be gathering it into my barn.

34 
 All these things, spake Jesus in parables, unto the multitudes, and, without a parable, was he speaking, nothing, unto them:

35 
 that it might be fulfilled, which was spoken through the prophet, saying-I will open, in parables, my mouth, I will bring up things hidden from the foundation!

 36 Then, dismissing the multitudes, he went into the house, and his disciples came near to him, saying- Make quite plain to us the parable of the darnel of the field.

37 
 And, he, answering, said-He that soweth the good seed, is the Son of Man;

38 
 And, the field, is the world, and, the good seed, these are the sons of the kingdom,-and, the darnel seeds, are the sons of the evil one;

 39 And, the enemy that sowed them, is the adversary, and, the harvest, is, the conclusion of an age, and, the reapers, are, messengers.

 40 Just, therefore, as collected is the darnel, and, with fire is burned, so, will it be in the conclusion of the age:-

41 
 The Son of Man will send forth his messengers, and they will collect, out of his kingdom, all the causes of stumbling, and the doers of lawlessness,

42 
 and will cast them into the furnace of fire: there, will be wailing and gnashing of teeth.

 43 Then, the righteous, will shine forth as the sun, in the kingdom of their Father. He that hath ears, let him hear!

The embryo Kingdom during the entire Gospel age. R5048:3, 3769:3

"Another parable" – These parables are related to each other, but should not be confounded. The first prepares the way for the other. The first deals with the individual; the second with the church collectively. R97:1, 4*; NS626:2

To show some of the difficulties which interfere with the best hearers, the best hearts, some with the best seed. R3769:3


Kingdom of heaven – Practically every parable which our Lord uttered was given to teach something respecting the character of the Kingdom. NS627:2

A man – The Lord Jesus.
R3769:3, 5048:6

Sowed good seed – The Gospel of the Kingdom from the Word of God, "He brought life and immortality to light through the Gospel." (2 Tim. 1:10)
R3769:3, 5048:6

Seeds of truth, the promises, which, springing up in the hearts of his disciples, transformed them to newness of life. R2634:1

"Which at the first began to be spoken by the Lord." (Heb. 2:3) R3769:3

Christ and the Apostles sowed the good seed, meanwhile gathering the ripe wheat of the Jewish nation. R5018:3


Same sower man, casting good seed, but "while men were sleeping" = as the Apostles died - the enemy came = "mystery of iniquity doth already work" "Nicolatianism" [see Frey notes]

Any attempt to organize became unauthorized and grew beyond the size of it's intent, ultimatley become "tare systems" to be bound together for destruction in the ecumenical movement at the end of the age. rcb

3rd Seal

Black Horse

Rev. 6:5 And, when he opened the third seal, I heard the third living creature, saying-Go! And I saw, and lo! a black horse, and he that was sitting thereon holding a pair of balances in his hand.

6 And I heard as a voice in the midst of the four living creatures, saying-A quart of wheat for, a denary, and three quarts of barley, for a denary,-and, the oil and the wine, do not wrong.

Since Horses are doctrines this is the new teaching for the new fourth century and beyond. Since black is the combination of all colors at once we suggest this is the time when the Roman Church began it's big tent approach accepting every kind of religious convert, changing the doctrine to cater to the masses. Once pure white but now too dark to see the original white - the doctrine of Christ - setting the stage for the papal inquisition. Black is the opposite of white so this was certainly a time when the light of the true gospel of Christ had all but gone out.

"Scales" or "Balance" = The suggestion is that this was the time when "church" direction was now to be based on economics.

The oil and wine represent holy spirit and doctrine.
rcb

There is a book written by my own mom called "The Chasm Between Christianity and the Bible" - Now she's not a known author, but in this book of rhymes, she says: "The first Church was pure, Jesus doctrines are sure- A conqueror whose horse is white. Each new age shows a horse on a descending course: Paganism, apostasy, night. Rev. 6:4-8 
rcb

The war in 1914 was the culmination of developed evils during the Gospel Age. St. Paul had predicted that there would be a “falling away” (2 Thes. 2:3), that it was al­ready working in his day (2 Thes. 2:7). It really had developed in a pronounced way by about 315 A.D., when it was considered proper to unite the Church with the Roman Empire, which union quickly developed a debasing and secularizing spirit in teaching and prac­tice. In Revelation 17-19 this union is blamed for all the false doctrines and secu­lar spirit that gradually engulfed the church as a nauseating flood, embracing as it did the theoretical and practical elements of heathen religions – under Christian names. The revelator styled this combination as Babylon (confusion), which indeed it was. A Magnificent Type Epiphany Bible Students

3rd Stage

Pergamos

313 AD to 799 AD

Third Messenger "Stars"
  1. Arius
  2. Tichonius
  3. Adelbert Desiderius
Rev. 2:12 And, unto the messenger of the assembly, in Pergamum, write:-These things, saith he that hath the sharp, two-edged sword:

13 I know where thou dwellest, where, the throne of Satan, is; and thou art holding fast my name, and didst not deny my faith, even in the days of Antipas, my witness, my faithful one, who was killed near you, where, Satan, dwelleth.

14 Nevertheless, I have against thee, a few things,-that thou hast there, such as hold fast the teaching of Balaam,-who went on to teach Balak to throw a cause of stumbling before the sons of Israel, to eat idol-sacrifices and to commit lewdness:

15 thus, even, thou, hast such as hold fast the teaching of the Nicolaitanes, in like manner.

16 Repent, therefore, otherwise, I come unto thee speedily,-and will fight against them, with the sword of my mouth.

17 He that hath an ear, let him hear what, the Spirit, is saying unto the assemblies. Unto him that overcometh, I will give, unto him, of the hidden manna, and I will give unto him a white stone, and, upon the stone, a new name written, which, no one, knoweth, save he that receiveth it.

THE CONGREGATION IN PERGAMOS – (Pergamos meaning "earthly elevation," having reference to that period in which the Papacy became greatly elevated as it united with Pagan Rome to form "The Holy Roman Empire") continued from 313 to 799, the principal Man being –ARIUS, who was presbyter at Alexander from AD313.
J Hoefle "The Seven Stars"



Verse 12: Jesus is still weilding the sharp two edged sword - the word of God - especially during this time when the Bible would become codified into 66 books, Arius fighting the good fight of faith against the Trinity that ultimately won out. rcb


verse 13: Antipas – Anti [against] papas [father or the pope]; one who protests against the pope. The true followers of the Master denounced the attempt to disobey the direct command of Jesus, "Call no man Father." Matt 23:9 R5993:2

The spirit of the Nicolataines increases, the beast rises into the Papacy, ready to crown Charlemagne in an official illicit union of church and state. The dragon or civil power under the auspices of Rome comes forth.

The white stone is a symbol of Christ given to individuals, the manna is the truth they would be supplied with along the way, the "new name" - the character of Christ that will belong to the devout overcomers... rcb

3rd Trumpet

Rev. 8:10 And, the third messenger, sounded; and there fell, out of heaven, a great star, burning as a torch, and it fell upon the third of the rivers, and upon the fountains of waters.

11 And, the name of the star, is called Wormwood; and the third of the waters became wormwood, and many of the men died of the waters, because they were made bitter.

This is the rise of the papacy. The star that fell out of heaven, wormwood, is the pope, the rivers and waters are the truth and it's supporters. The teachings became perverted so now spiritual life in Christ was near impossible due to the now complete obscuring of the doctrine of Christ - the white horse. See column one Seal comments. rcb


3rd Bowl of Wrath

Rev. 16:4 And the third poured out the bowl of himself into the rivers and into the fountains of the waters; and it became blood.

5 And I heard the messenger of the waters saying: Righteous art thou, the one existing and who was, the bountiful one, because these things thou hast judged;

6 because blood of holy ones and of prophets they poured out, and blood to them thou gavest to drink; worthy they are.

7
And I heard the altar saying: Yes, O Lord the God the almighty, true and righteous the judgments of thee.


The angel of the waters – Pastor Russell, the Messenger of the Truth (waters).

Again we can see in comparing the trumpets and the bowls some similar things, water in this instance. The papacy resulted from the bitter waters of polluted truth. It's demise is from the pure Truth (waters) given in due time.

Pastor Russell's third volume "Thy Kingdom Come" added to the ulcers of Rome's adherents as their true history was laid bare, with Napolean delivering the blow to end papal sovereignty over the nations, the release of this book surely turned her waters of truth into the deathly reality of actual historic facts. It also pointed out God's promises of "The Restoration of Israel", since the blood of both "saints" and "prophets" were poured out, truly the promise of their return will be blood upon their own papal heads, for them to "drink" or be forced to accept the facts of their own infamous careers.

In verse 7 the voice from the alter is an allusion to Pastor Russell's chapter 10 "God's Stone Witness" about the Great Pyramid in Gizeh being an altar in the midst of and on the border of the land Isaiah 19:19-20 This book, "Thy Kingdom Come" volume 3 in the Studies in the Scriptures series and constitutes the third bowl. rcb

It should be noted, too, that Volume 3 contained a moderate explanation of the Great Pyramid of Giza, showing from the prophetic statement of Isa. 19:19‑22 that the “altar to the Lord in the midst of the land of Egypt” was indeed “a sign and a witness” to the great Plan of the Ages as contained in the Bible. Thus the pertinence of v. 7: “I heard another (angel) out of the altar” – in “the midst of the land of Egypt.” This truth, too, has been completely rejected by some, and distorted by others since Brother Russell’s death. No. 351 "In Memoriam" Epiphany Bible Students

3rd PARABLE

Mustard Seed

Matt 13:31 Another parable, put he before them, saying-The kingdom of the heavens is like unto, a grain of mustard seed, which a man took and sowed in his field;

32 
 which, indeed, is, less, than all seeds, but, when grown, is greater than garden-plants, and becometh a tree,-so that the birds of heaven come, and lodge among its branches.

As a mustard seed is very small, yet produces a large bush, so that the fowls of the air may lodge in its branches, so this illustrates how the gospel of the Kingdom would, from a small beginning, attain to a considerable size. Its size would not be great among the trees, but great among bushes or herbage. Thus the message of Christ received at first only by the poor and the few of Israel, has finally grown to such important dimensions that the fowls like to gather in its branches. But let us remember that the fowls, according to our Lord's interpretation of a previous parable, represent the servants of the Wicked One. So then the teaching of this parable would lead us to conclude that the Church of Christ, at one time, was so unimportant in the world that it was a shame and a dishonor to belong to it, but that ultimately it would become honorable and great and the Adversary's servants would have pleasure in its shade. This development the Scriptures represent as being Babylon, declaring that, as a whole, with the various branches and denominations, the nominal Church of Christ is [R4636 : page 205] Babylonish. Hearken to the Lord's words; "She has become the hold of every foul spirit and the cage of every unclean and hateful bird."

This period of time is the immense growth of the roman church to cover the full roman empire beginning with 313 AD Constantine followed by the fall of the western empire in 476 AD then 539 AD Justinian and the desolating abomination...and leading right up to Charlemagne 800 AD

The fouls or birds of heaven are the fallen ones, both men and angels, who take control of the hierarchy of this gigantic system of branches. rcb
4th Seal

Livid Horse

Rev. 6:7 And, when he opened the fourth seal, I heard the voice of the fourth living creature, saying-Go!

8 And I saw, and lo! a livid horse,-and he that was sitting thereupon had for a name, Death, and, Hades, was following with him; and there was given unto them authority over the fourth of the earth, to slay with sword, and with famine, and with death, and by the wild beasts of the earth.
[Rotherham]

The Holy Roman Empire is born, "hades" = purgatory

Papal Dark Ages. Now
Catholics 1/4 earth's population and/ or land areas...

The evil time of the Crusades and the Inquisition.
The horse is now sickly green [will eventually become earth worship - rcb]

[Bro. Bob Jone's Rev. Study suggests "green" is the doctrine of "Justification by Faith" - a faint green glow of improvement emerging during this time period. This would presumeably lead to white horse conditions of Rev 19 rcb]

The one sitting on him - "Death" is the Pope. "the unseen" or "hades" is a symbol for the doctrine of purgatory.  The "holy" Roman Empire had control over the Christian world which was "the fourth part of the earth" [society]. Jews, Mohammedans and Heathen making up the other 3 parts. To "kill with sword" refers to the controversies over doctrine and a time when Christians killed other Christians both literally and figuratively, pronouncing one another heretics.  The Waldenses were killed by the thousands for example.

To kill "with famine" describes an era when the Word of God was hidden by the Papacy. "Not a famine for bread nor a thirst for water but of the hearing and the doing of the Word of God." To kill "with death" is symbolic for being excommunicated. To kill "with the wild beasts of the earth" is symbolically describes how the papacy used earthly governments to control heresies. rcb

The Crusades were a series of religious wars initiated, supported, and sometimes directed by the Christian Latin Church in the medieval period. The best known of these military expeditions are those to the Holy Land in the period between 1095 and 1291 that were intended to conquer Jerusalem and its surrounding area from Muslim rule. Beginning with the First Crusade, which resulted in the conquest of Jerusalem in 1099, dozens of military campaigns were organised, providing a focal point of European history for centuries.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crusades

4th Stage

Thyatira

799 AD to 1309 AD

Fourth Messenger "Stars"
  1. Claudius of Turin
  2. Ratramnus
  3. Hugh Capet
  4. Adalbert of Prague
  5. Berengar of Tours
  6. Peter Abelard
  7. Peter de Brys
  8. Henry of Lausanne
  9. Arnold of Brescia
  10. John Waldo
Rev. 2:18 And, unto the messenger of the assembly, in Thyatira, write:-These things, saith the Son of God, who hath his eyes like a flame of fire, and his feet like unto glowing copper:

 19 I know thy works, and thy love, and faith, and ministry, and endurance,-and that, thy last works, are more than the first.

20 Nevertheless, I have against thee, that thou sufferest the woman Jezebel, she who calleth herself a prophetess, and is teaching and leading astray my own servants to commit lewdness and to eat idol sacrifices;

21 and I gave her time, that she might repent, and she willeth not to repent out of her lewdness.

22 Lo! I cast her into a bed, and them who are committing adultery with her, into great tribulation,- except they repent out of her works;

23 and, her children, will I slay with death;-and all the assemblies shall get to know, that, I, am he that searcheth reins and hearts, and will give unto you, each one, according to your works.

24 But, unto you, I say,-the rest who are in Thyatira, as many as have not this teaching, such as have not come to know the deep things of Satan, as they say, I do not cast upon you any other burden;

25 nevertheless, what ye have, hold fast, till I shall have come.

26 And, he that overcometh, and keepeth throughout my works, I will, give unto him, authority over the nations;

27 and he shall shepherd them with a sceptre of iron,-as, vessels of earthenware, are dashed in pieces:- as, I also, have received from my Father.

28 And I will give unto him the morning star.

29 He that hath an ear, let him hear what, the Spirit, is saying unto the assemblies.

THE CONGREGATION IN THYATIRA – (Thyatira meaning "the sweet perfume of a sacrifice" in allusion to the elevating sacrifices of the true church during the drunken revel­ings of the apostate Roman Church) continued from 799 to 1309.
J Hoefle "The Seven Stars

Notes: Verse 18 "eyes like flame of fire" Christ perception of all "trying reins and hearts"-their true motives.

"feet like glowing copper" = copper is a symbol for the human nature. This is indicating Christ's having walked this earth = "polished copper"
"glowing" from the  fiery trials during this time.

Verse 19 is about Christ's footstep followers who suffered these persecutions.
they displayed "works" "love" "faith" "ministry" and "endurance" in this severe time.

"The Crusades" started around 1095 AD, later the medieval Inquisition started around 1184, causing the last works of the Thyatira church to be greater than their first as their sufferings increased.

By verses 20-23 the false Church is now called "Jezebel" to distinguish this time as when the "Holy Roman Empire" engaged in "adultery" by mixing her false religious toxins together along with her illicit state governance for the persecuting of the saints.

The nations cooperating with her are promised a table of woe at "The Great Tribulation" which would begin in 1914, when the non repentant nations involved would lose their subsequently born generations through war, famine and pestilence and other plagues during their "judgement day" as He that "searcheth reigns and hearts" began taking control over earth's affairs.

The overcomers in verses 26 and 27 are ultimately given control over the nations and given the spiritual nature as shown in verse 28 which infers Job's description of the time when the morning stars - God's angelic creation - "shouted for joy" while assisting the Logos in the work of Creation. What a shout they shall make in the future, we hope to hear some day. rcb

Job 38:6 Whereupon were the foundations thereof fastened? Or who laid the corner-stone thereof,

7When the morning stars sang together, And all the sons of God shouted for joy?
4th Trumpet

Rev. 8:12 And, the fourth messenger, sounded; and the third of the sun was smitten, and the third of the moon, and the third of the stars,-in order that the third of them might be darkened, and the day might not shine for the third of it, and the night, in like manner.

13 And I saw, and I heard one eagle, flying in mid-heaven, saying with a loud voice-Woe! woe! woe! unto them that are dwelling upon the earth, by reason of the remaining voices of the trumpet, of the three messengers who are about to sound.

"a third of" = [from wikipedia] - The Inquisition, as a church-court, had no jurisdiction over Muslims and Jews as
such.[10] Generally, the Inquisition was concerned only with the heretical behaviour of Catholic adherents or converts.[11]

The darkest period of Church history, obscuring the light of the sun = the true Gospel, the light of the moon = the Mosaic Covenant. A third of the stars = Christian lights that fell into darkness from their misdeeds during this time. rcb

Verse 13 says "one eagle". Since numbers are literal we should establish a single individual as wiser than the others at this time who was able to pronounce the upcoming three woes. Was it Claudius, Waldo or other? rcb


4th Bowl of Wrath

Rev. 16:8 And the fourth poured out the bowl of himself on the sun; and was given to him to burn the men in fire.

9 And were burned the men heat great, and blasphemed the name of the God of that having authority over plagues these; and not they reformed to give to him glory.



The fourth bowl appeared in 1897; and it certainly affirmed its title, “The Battle of Armageddon,” in that “power was given to scorch men with fire.” It pointed out the prevalent sins among rulers, clergy, aristocracy and labor; and was a true fulfilment of Jesus’ words in John 16‑8‑11: “When the Holy Spirit is come, it will reprove the world of sin (the wrongs they are committing), of righteousness (point out the right way to do), and of judgment” (warn them of the coming judgment, which in this instance was in its initial phase to be the “battle of the great day of God Almighty”). But, “as it was in the days of Noah,” they neither heeded nor wanted to hear that message – “repented not to give God glory."

It should be noted that the “fourth bowl” described events that are happening today as though the book were written this year; whereas, it was written 78 years ago. The forecasts of that book are in part a fulfilment of Dan. 5:25‑29 – the much‑quoted “handwriting on the wall.” It explained that the statement, “The kingdom is divided, and given to the Medes and Persians” (v. 28) indicated that Christendom would be divided into two hostile camps: a conservative camp, consisting of church, state and capital, and a radical camp, consisting of trade unionists, socialists, communists, anarchists and nihilists.

At the time the book was written these antagonistic factions had only a faint beginning, which developed to some degree up to 1914; but it was the outbreak of the war in 1914 that caused a clear cleavage between them, as typified by Elijah smiting Jordan (type of Christendom and the curse) – when the waters (peoples) of that river developed into two distinct warring factions. The terse substance of Volume 4 – “The Battle of‑Armageddon” – gave 1914 as the end of “the times of the Gentiles” (Luke 21: 24); Great Babylon’s judgement and downfall; the overthrow of Satan’s empire, to be followed by God’s kingdom on earth. All of these things were set forth in precise detail and accuracy – so much that, when the great events began to transpire in 1914, it directed the world’s attention to Brother Russell as the outstanding interpreter and Bible lecturer of his time, the greatest religious teacher in Christendom. And in the Fall of 1917 the czarist regime in Russia was overthrown, it being one of the strongest and most absolute monarchies that had ever existed in all human history. There the text began to be fulfilled, “the mountains (strong autocratic governments) carried into the midst of the sea (the lawless elements of society).” This feature of prophecy has now been carried to a completion; the last autocracy being Ethiopia, which was toppled in 1974. 
No. 351 "In Memoriam" Epiphany Bible Students


This is an ideal setup for Pastor Russell's fourth volume of Scripture Studies titled "The Battle of Armageddon", where the author takes Babylon to task for their tremendous war preparations expenditures.  The nations chose not to reform from their militaristic ways and instead "repented not" and began World War I in 1914. This volume was "poured on the sun" in the sense that the Roman Church was the oracle of God's Word during this time and it brought a scathing or rather scorching indictment. Notice "mankind" is merely "scorched" not burned nor destroyed - with the warning to Christendom which this volume indeed was. rcb

4th PARABLE

Leaven in the Meal

Matt 13:33 Another parable, spake he unto them:-The kingdom of the heavens is like, unto leaven, which a woman took and hid in three measures of flour until, the whole, was leavened.

The three measures of meal are faith, hope and love.


"LEAVEN HIDDEN IN THE MEAL"

"The parable of the "leaven" (v. 33) illustrates the process by which, as was foretold, the Church would get into the wrong condition. As a woman would take her batch of flour for baking and put leaven (yeast) in it and the result would be that the mass would become leavened, so it would be with the Church of Christ; the food of the entire household would become leavened or corrupted. Every portion would become more or less vitiated with the leaven of false doctrines which would permeate the entire mass. Thus today nearly every doctrine inculcated by Jesus and his Apostles has become more or less perverted or twisted by the errors of the dark ages." R4636
5th Seal

[no horse]

Rev. 6:9 And, when he opened the fifth seal, I saw, beneath the altar, the souls of them who had been slain because of the word of God and because of the witness which they held.

10 And they cried out with a loud voice, saying-How long, O Sovereign, the Holy and True, dost thou not vindicate and avenge our blood from them that dwell upon the earth?

11 And there was given to them, each one, a white robe, and it was bidden them, that they should rest yet a little while-until the number should be made full of their fellow-servants also, and their brethren, who were about to be slain as even, they.

[Rotherham]


This is a picture of consecration as well as a depiction of our Lord's ransom [John 3:16] these are not necessarily literally killed.
saying "how long" could introduce the chronology aspect of the Bible

"judge and avenge" where protestantism pointed out the destiny of the antichrist system as shown in the Bible that would ultimately punish "those dwelling on the earth" or those in positions of society. "White robe" is justification by faith. "Rest a little while" indicates a further period of waiting for glorification as the full number of the elect church. rcb



5th Stage

Sardis

1309 AD to 1479 AD

Fifth Messenger "Stars"
  1. Marsiglio
  2. John Tauler
  3. John Wycliffe
  4. John Huss
  5. Jerome of Prague
Rev. 3: 1 And, unto the messenger of the assembly, in Sardis, write:-These things, saith he that hath the seven Spirits of God, and the seven stars: I know thy works,-that, a name, thou hast, that thou art living, and art, dead.

2 Become thou watchful, and strengthen the things that remain, that were about to die; for I have not found thy works fulfilled before my God.

3 Remember, therefore, how thou hast received, and didst hear, and keep it and repent. If then thou shall not watch, I will have come as a thief, and in nowise shalt thou get to know, during what sort of hour, I will have come upon thee.

4 Nevertheless, thou hast a few names, in Sardis, which have not defiled their garments; and they shall walk with me in white, because they are, worthy.

5 He that overcometh, shall, thus, array himself in white garments, and in nowise will I blot out his name, from the book of life; and I will confess his name before my Father, and before his messengers.

6 He that hath an ear, let him hear what, the Spirit, is saying unto the assemblies.

THE CONGREGATTON IN SARDIS – (Sardis meaning "that which remains" in reference to the brief period just before the Reformation by Sects) continued from 1309 to 1479, the Principal Man being Marsiglio, who officiated from 1309 to 1343.
J Hoefle "The Seven Stars"


...seven angels to the seven churches," each of which had a 'principal man' (a 'prince')--with two 'principal men' (or 'princes') in the Laodicean, or seventh epoch. The 'principal man' during the sounding of the fifth trumpet was Marsiglio, whose specific ministry was from 1309 to 1328 A.D, His ministry was climaxed in 1324 by the appearance of his book "The Defender of the Peace"--a work which aimed at the papal evils of that time. ...
" J. Hoefle "BROTHERS FROM EVERY VIEWPOINT"
5th Trumpet

Rev. 9:1 And, the fifth messenger, sounded; and I saw a star, out of heaven, fallen unto the earth, and there was given unto him the key of the shaft of the abyss.

 2 And he opened the shaft of the abyss; and there came up a smoke out of the shaft, as the smoke of a great furnace, and the sun and the air were darkened, by reason of the smoke of the shaft.

3 And, out of the smoke, came forth, locusts, upon the earth; and there was given unto them licence, as the scorpions of the earth have licence.

 4 And it was bidden them that they should not injure the herbage of the earth, nor any green thing, nor any tree,-but only the men who have not the seal of God upon their foreheads.

5 And it was given unto them, that they should not slay them, but that they should be tormented five months; and, the torture of them, was as of a scorpion's torture, whensoever it smiteth a man.

6 And, in those days, shall men seek death, and in nowise shall find it, and shall covet to die, and death fleeth from them.

7 And, the likenesses of the locusts, were like unto horses prepared for battle; and, upon their heads, as it were crowns, like unto gold, and, their faces, were as the faces of men,

8 and, they had hair, as the hair of women, and, their teeth, were, as of lions,

 9 and they had breastplates as breastplates of iron, and, the sound of their wings, was as the sound of chariots of many horses, running into battle;

10 and they have tails like unto scorpions, and stings, and, in their tails, is their licence to injure men five months.

11 They have over them, as king, the messenger of the abyss, whose name, in Hebrew, is Abaddon "=Destroyer", and, in the Greek, he hath for name, Destroyer.

12 The first, Woe, hath passed away, lo! there come, yet, two, Woes, after these things.

The air – The Greek word here is used symbolically to represent government or controlling power over the earth. R152:6

Rev. 9:1-2 A false star is referred to here who fell - the pope. His having the key to the abyss is his ability to speak ex cathedra any and all things false = the black smoke of confusion that is the papal decretals and decrees. The true saints were thrust into a furnace of affliction during these Crusades and Inquisitions, during which time the light of the true gospel was hard to see. rcb

Rev. 9:3

"We offer the true interpretation of the "locusts" of Rev, 9:3 as describing the diabolic teaching of indulgences (a devastating 'pest' in every respect) which flourished during the symbolic five months --150 symbolic days, actually 150 years -­of Rev. 9:5. The practice of indulgences appeared during the Crusades--innocently enough promising 'indulgence' to all who offered their service in the crusading armies attempting to wrest the Holy Land from the "Terrible Turks." In time the teaching was developed as an aid to fill the empty coffers of the greedy money ­loving popes of that time...

...seven angels to the seven churches," each of which had a 'principal man' (a 'prince')--with two 'principal men' (or 'princes') in the Laodicean, or seventh epoch. The 'principal man' during the sounding of the fifth trumpet was Marsiglio, whose specific ministry was from 1309 to 1328 A.D, His ministry was climaxed in 1324 by the appearance of his book "The Defender of the Peace"--a work which aimed at the papal evils of that time. ...

If we add 150 years to 1328, we come to l478, when we find John Wessel just beginning his ministry as the 'principal man' sounding the sixth trumpet. This trumpet continued to sound for 391 years (See Rev. 9:15), until 1870 when That Servant began to sound the seventh trumpet..
..John Wessel saw this clearly enough (although we doubt he understood the correct interpretation of Rev. 9). That faithful mouthpiece of the Lord is rated by history as "the most renowned scholar of his time--a man of rare erudition--a reformer before the Reformation." He aligned himself with the anti-papal party and protested the growing paganizing of the Papacy, contending that "Sin can be forgiven by none but God." That battle cry of the sixth angel was hurled forth by Martin Luther as a mighty thunder; and, supplemented by others of his day, forced the Great Reform Coun­cil of Trent to declare an end to the abuse of indulgences in the year 1562. Thus, the sting of the locusts began to subside in 1478 through the exposures of Wessel and others just 'five months' (l50 literal years) after the death of Marsiglio--and was completely nullified by 1562."

"...when we consider the time setting when the antitypical locusts of Rev. 9:3 made their appear­ance. It occurred when "the fifth angel sounded" (Rev. 9: 1).  The "trumpet" of the fifth angel had already completed its work by the year l479-" J. Hoefle "BROTHERS FROM EVERY VIEWPOINT"

Rev. 9:4 Grass – People. 1 Pet. 1:24
The Earth – Organized society
Green thing = converts?

According to the Tischendorf Notes "neither any green thing" is not found in the Sinaitic MS.

Seal of God – Present Truth. Not Present (2023) Truth but Present (Wycliffe's day) Truth.

In their foreheads – Their intellects.

Rev. 9:5
slay=not always literal - Romans 8:36 Even as it is written, For thy sake we are killed all the day long; We were accounted as sheep for the slaughter.

Rev. 9:6
death = political death as nations under tyrannous restraint sought national reformation but were thwarted. See CTR HG77:6

Rev. 9:7
Locusts = Indulgences
Horses=doctrines
"as it were crowns" meaning not really crowns
"like unto gold"
"
Gold" = divine nature. They were imposters not authorized by the true God
 but a false church.

Rev. 9:8 "Hair"= long professions, explanations "Women" = churches. These are false doctrinal teaching using their "teeth as lions" meaning verbal arguments with authority.

Rev. 9:9 "breastplates of iron" = authorized by Rome [corroborates the iron legs of Nebuchadnezzar's statue in Daniel.] This is a counter to the "breastplate of righteousness" in Eph. 6:14 which comes through Christ alone.

Rev. 9:10 Scorpions tails = the torturous after effects of these events.

Rev. 9:11 Abaddon is the Pope.

Rev. 9:12 This was the first "woe trumpet." rcb


5th Bowl of Wrath

Rev. 16:10 And the fifth poured out the bowl of him on the throne of the wild-beast. And became the kingdom of him darkened; and they bit the tongues of themselves because of the anguish,

11 and they blasphemed the God of the heaven because of the pains of themselves and because of the ulcers of themselves; and not they reformed from the works of themselves.


In 1899 came the fifth “bowl” – that “poured out his vial upon the seat of the beast; and his kingdom was full of darkness (great portions of the beast’s teachings were proven to be error, superstition and tradition – the “precepts of men”); and they gnawed their tongues for pain” (v. 10). It should not cause much argument when we declare that Volume 5 was Brother Russell’s masterpiece. His analysis of the Holy Spirit, of Life Everlasting and Immortality, of the Trinity, the Soul, of Sheol ‑ Hades ‑ Gehenna, left his opponents “speechless.” Of a truth, “they gnawed their tongues for pain.” So clear and convincing were the presentations of the fifth “bowl” that many segments of the secular press gave it unstinted praise; although antitypical Saul and the lesser lights “repented not” (v. 11)
No. 351 "In Memoriam" Epiphany Bible Students

Brother Russell's 5th Volume "The Atonement Between God and Man" included an unassailable treatise against the doctrine of the trinity, the chief of the creeds being the throne of the beast. This put the lie to Romanism who had no answers ("naw their tongues") against Pastor Russell's Scriptural treatise on the subject. By refusing to accept the falsehood of the trinity, they in a sense "blaspheme God" because
in the doctrine of the trinity they keep insisting that Jesus is "God" meaning equal to the Heavenly Father, when it is the Most High God who "anoints" the Son Jesus, (the greater always anoints the lesser. Jesus said "My Father is greater than I" John 14:28) rcb

5th PARABLE

Hidden Treasure

Matt 13:44 The kingdom of the heavens is like unto, a treasure hid in the field, which a man, finding, hid,- and, by reason of his joy, withdraweth and selleth whatsoever he hath, and buyeth that field.

TREASURE HID IN A FIELD
The desirability of obtaining joint-heirship with Christ in his Millennial Kingdom, is pictured in the parable of "the treasure hidden in the field." The finder, realizing its value, desired it for himself and had such faith in it that he disposed of all of his property in order to buy that field, which he believed to contain the precious treasure. Only those who will appreciate the Gospel message will gain its glorious promises. If we love the present life with its joys and prospects, its hopes and ambitions, then we will labor for these, but if we intelligently hear and, by faith, believe the Gospel offer of this age of a share with Christ in his Millennial Kingdom, then in proportion to our faith and appreciation will be our self-sacrificing zeal to attain that prize. Whoever believes the message of the Kingdom will find his faith an inspiration, indeed a necessary inspiration, to the attainment of the prize, for it will cost all that he has of earthly blessings; and unless he has faith that he will find the prize, he will surely be unwilling to sacrifice all he has for it. The field belongs to God. He has put the treasure there. He offers it for sale to any willing to pay the price. The buyer is the Lord and those who accept his invitation to join with him in the sacrifice of their earthly interests that they may be sharers with him in his heavenly glories – in the work of the Millennial Age, to unearth all that treasure in the blessing of the world of mankind. R4636

The Lord's followers are to reckon that no sacrifice is too great to attain the blessing; indeed, the Kingdom can be attained at no less cost than the surrender of all their earthly hopes and aims. HG439:1

Present Truth. Not Present (2023) Truth but Present (Wycliffe's day) Truth.






6th Seal

Rev. 6:12 And I saw, when he opened the sixth seal, that a, great earthquake, took place; and, the sun, became black as sackcloth of hair, and, the full moon, became as blood,

13 and, the stars of heaven, fell to the earth, as, a fig-tree, sheddeth her winter figs, when, by a great wind, it is shaken,

14 and, the heaven, was withdrawn, as a scroll rolling itself up, and, every mountain and island, out of their places, were shaken.

15 And, the kings of the earth, and the great men, and the rulers of thousands, and the rich, and the mighty, and every bondman and freeman, hid themselves within the caves and within the rocks of the mountains;

16 and they say, unto the mountains and unto the rocks-Fall upon us, and hide us from the face of him that sitteth upon the throne, and from the anger of the Lamb;

17 Because the great day of their anger is come, and who is able to stand?

[Rotherham]

Rev. 6:12 The French Revolution is the earthquake. It's barbarism turned the teaching of religion black with darkness of papacy's professions (hair) which coincidentally created a villainous character out of world Jewry, to whom their schemes always attach blood libels and their subsequent persecutions and pogroms. rcb

Symbolically, the creeds (the moon of the papal heavens) have become repugnant, though still
hypocritically professed.
Symbolically, also the light of the Mosaic Law
(the moon of the true heavens) has been made to
appear evil by the claims of the clergy that the
typical sacrifices were bloody and barbaric.—
D590, 592

The first world war was the start of the tribulations as shown by Br Russell. It would have led to the full
establishment of the Kingdom was it not for God delaying it a little longer until some more events were
to occur as shown in chapter 7.
According to Bible chronology and the book of Daniel chapter 12, the time of the end started soon
after the French revolution in 1799 and during which time knowledge started to increase.
Whilst biblical knowledge was also increasing among faithful Christians, the worldly knowledge was
overtaking it causing a spiritual darkness that was shaking up religious institutions as shown in Rev
6:12-14
When WWI started in Europe, in the centre of Babylon’s and her daughters, it seemed that Br Russell
was right and the predicted end was coming.
In order to avoid this predicted end to occur, those nations turned to the mountains for help. One was
the US and it got involved with its allies in 1917, the war was won by the allies and the inevitable have
gotten delayed. That was what God had intended unbeknown to Br Russell who had passed away by
then. Frederick Delon "Revelation Chapter 6:12 through 7:3"

Rev. 6:13 Here the untimely figs and fig tree are not natural Israel as depicted in Volume 7 "The Finished Mystery" even though it is an inviting solution. If we are to be consistent however, then we are again referring to Christians as the symbolic "synagogue of Satan who are affirming themselves to be, Jews, and are not,- but say what is false". So here we add the commentary from mostholyfaith.com

"We should notice that it is as a fig tree casts her untimely figs. Natural Israel (the fig tree) should have been ripe for harvest at the time of the first advent. But instead of supplying the full number of the body of Christ, they proved unworthy and their untimely (unripe) figs (fruitage) were cast out. – Just so in the harvest of the Gospel Age for nominal spiritual Israel."

Remaining question, is it to be (paraphrasing)"as a fig tree sheddeth her figs" or could it be instead "while the fig tree sheddeth her figs"?
In which case it can refer to premature Zionist hopes? However since Zionism really ignited with Herzl in the late 1800's I still believe this is a metaphor for the fact that during this period just prior to Jesus' return, it resembled the same thing that occurred with natural Israel at His first advent, they were simply unripe - unprepared to receive Him.  rcb

Rev. 6:14 Catholicism and Protestantism begin to unite in 1846 with the Ecumenical movement.

As their confusion increases, Catholicism and Protestantism roll together for self-protection. D258; R5349:4

They believe that in union there is strength. R1947:6

The extremes of the ecclesiastical heavens, Catholic and Protestant, will be drawn together. R4698:6

Rev. 6:15, figuratively describes that time of falling of kingdoms when every mountain (kingdom) and island shall be moved. The kings and chief ones as well as bondmen will recognize in this trouble that "The great day of his wrath is come," and will seek to be covered and protected by the great mountains (kingdoms) of earth, and to be hid in the great rocks of this world (secret societies). But they shall not be able to deliver them in the day of the Lord's anger, for all the kingdoms of the world shall be thrown down, and instead of these mountains (kingdoms) "the kingdom of the Lord becomes a great mountain, and fills the whole earth." Daniel 2:35,45. R409

And the kings of the earth.— The aristocracy

And the great men.— The clergy. (Rev. 18:23,
comment.) Rendered "nobles" in Mark 6:21. See
Job. 12:2; Isa. 9:15.

[And the rich men,] and the chief captains,
AND THE RICH MEN.— The high military
officers.
Rendered "high captains" in Mark 6:21. The
magnates and financiers.
 
And the mighty men.— The labor organizers.

And every bondman.— Member of a labor
organization.

And every free man.— Other worker (if not a
bond-slave of Christ).

"The Finished Mystery" 122

Hid themselves in the dens.— See Isa. 2:19-21.
And in the rocks of the mountains.— "As the
trouble increases, men will seek, but in vain, for
protection in the great rocks and fortresses of
society (Free Masonry, Odd Fellowship, and
Trades Unions, Guilds, Trusts, and all societies
secular and ecclesiastical), and in the mountains
(governments) of earth."— B139; Jer. 3:23; Hos.
10:8.

Revelation 6:16
And said to the mountains and rocks, Fall on us. -"The Greek word epi, here used, is generally translated on, but has also the significance of over (Rev. 5:10) and about, and is so translated many times in the common
version. The thought is that of protection, not of
destruction. The common view of this passage,
that it teaches that wicked men will get faith
enough to pray for literal mountains to fall, is
absurd. The real fulfillment is already beginning:
the great, the rich, and no less the poor, are
seeking to the mountains and rocks and caves for
shelter from the darkening storm of trouble
which all see is gathering."— B139; Hos. 10:8; Hab. 3:6.

“The heavens (the present religious systems) shall be rolled to­gether as a scroll: and all their host shall fall down, as the leaf falleth off from the vine, and as a falling fig from the fig tree.” (Isa. 34:4) The end of all this is graphically set forth in Rev. 6:14: “The heaven departed as a scroll when it is rolled together; and every mountain (powerful absolute monarchies) and island (republics and lenient governments) were moved out of their places” – of which we have seen so much since the collapse of the powerful Czarist regime in Russia in 1917.
J Hoefle 163 Retrospect-and-prospect

Day of his wrath – "The seven last plagues; for in them is filled up the wrath of God." Rev. 15:1

Rev. 6:17 Because Satan knew
that Jesus' Kingdom was about to come, and helped his schemers and planners, demons with corporations to somehow avoid (if it were possible) Christ's "Day of Wrath" "Day of Judgement"= 1914 Today we find the large demonic plan had it's beginnings in the days of Rockefeller and J.P. Morgan et. al.

For MORE on this please see the Revelation 13 study by Martin Reuter and Roman Wigienka. rcb

6th Stage

Philadelphia

1479 AD to 1874 AD

Sixth Messenger "Stars"
  1. John Wessel
  2. Jerome Savonarola
  3. Martin Luther
  4. Ulrich Zwingli
  5. Balthazer Hubmaier
  6. Michael Servetus
  7. John Wesley
  8. Thomas Cranmer
  9. Robert Browne
  10. George Fox
  11. Thomas Campbell
  12. Barton W. Stone
  13. William Miller
Rev. 3:7 And, unto the messenger of the assembly, in Philadelphia, write:-These things, saith he that is holy, he that is true, he that hath the key of David, he that openeth and no one shall shut, and shutteth and no one openeth:

8 I know thy works,-lo! I have set before thee an open door, as to which, no one, can shut it,-that thou hast, a little strength, and hast kept my word, and hast not denied my name.

9 Lo! I give them of the synagogue of Satan, who are affirming themselves to be, Jews, and are not,- but say what is false,-lo! I will cause them, that they shall have come, and shall bow down before thy feet, and shall get to know that, I, loved thee.

10 Because thou didst keep my word of endurance, I also, will keep thee out of the hour of trial, which is about to come upon the whole habitable world, to try them that dwell upon the earth.

11 I come quickly: hold fast that which thou hast, that, no one, take thy crown.

12 He that overcometh, I will make, him, a pillar in the sanctuary of my God, and, outside, shall he in nowise go forth any more; and I will write upon him the name of my God, and the name of the city of my God, the new Jerusalem, which cometh down out of heaven from my God, and I will write upon him my new name.

13 He that hath an ear, let him hear what, the Spirit, is saying unto the assemblies.

THE CONGREGATION IN PHILADELPHIA – (Philadelphia meaning "love of a brother," indicating the strong brotherly love that prevailed especially among persecuted Protestants during this epoch) continued from 1479 to 1874.
J Hoefle "The Seven Stars"

Rev. 3:7,8 Joint heirship comes to light the time when the door is still open to the high calling.

Rev. 3:9 "Synagoge of Satan" is those who claimed to be Christians and are not. This was a key feature of this time period. At the end of the time period it was brother Russell who maintained that "the Ransom" was the determining doctrine as to who was a true Christian or not.

Rev. 3:10 "The dark night in which no man can work" John 9:4 = 1914" rcb

Rev. 3:11 Invisibly in 1874
"Behold I come as a thief" Rev. 16:15

Rev. 3:12-13 Special rewards of the little flock, the firstborns. "Write upon" their characters = stamped with the character of Christ. rcb

of interest:

1914
-360
=1554 AD




1914 is (was to be) the day of vengeance. rcb


It will be of little consequence then that the ecclesiastical heavens (the religious powers, Papal and Protestant) will [D552] have rolled together as a scroll. (Isa. 34:4; Rev. 6:14) The combined religious power of Christendom will be utterly futile against the rising tide of anarchy when the dread crisis is reached. Before that great army "all the host of heaven [the church nominal] shall be dissolved, and the heavens shall be rolled together as a scroll [the two great bodies which constitute the ecclesiastical heavens; viz., Papacy and Protestantism, as the two distinct ends of the scroll are even now rapidly approaching each other, rolling together, as we have shown]; and all their host shall fall down [fall off, drop out; not all at once, but gradually, yet rapidly] as the leaf falleth off from the vine, and as a falling fig from the fig tree" (Isa. 34:4); and finally these "heavens, being on fire, shall be dissolved, and the elements [of which they are composed] shall melt with fervent heat." 2 Pet. 3:12 D551








6th Trumpet

Rev. 9:13 And, the sixth messenger, sounded; and I heard one voice, from among the horns of the altar of gold which is before God,

14 saying unto the sixth messenger, who was holding the trumpet-Loose the four messengers, who are bound at the great river Euphrates.

15 And the four messengers were loosed, who had been prepared for the hour, and day, and month, and year, that they should slay the third of men.

16 And, the number of the armies of the horsemen, was twice ten thousand times ten thousand-I heard the number of them.

17 And, thus, saw I the horses in the vision,-and them who were sitting upon them, having breastplates as of fire and hyacinth and brimstone;-and, the heads of the horses, were as heads of lions, and, out of their mouths, come forth fire and smoke and brimstone:

18 by these three plagues, were slain, the third part of mankind, by reason of the fire and the smoke and the brimstone, that proceedeth out of their mouths;

19 for, the licence of the horses, is, in their mouth, and in their tails, for, their tails, are like unto serpents, having heads, and, with them, they injure.

20 And, the rest of mankind who were not slain by these plagues, repented not of the works of their hands,-that they should not do homage unto the demons, nor unto the idols of gold and of silver and of copper and of stone and of wood, which can neither see nor hear nor walk;

21 Neither repented they of their murders, or of their sorceries, or of their lewdnesses, or of their thefts.

"An hour, and a day – 391 years, 15 days" CT Russell HG78:1

Rev. 9:13 The golden altar – This is the golden or incense altar in the holy. mhf.com

v. 9:14 This is the voice of the prayers of the saints (past martyrs) telling the angel (present martyrs) to allow the judgement of Babylon to begin.

Crying out a second time - parenthetical to Rev. 6:10 "And they cried with a loud voice, saying, How long, O Lord, holy and true, dost thou not judge and avenge our blood on them that dwell on the earth? rcb

Another thought based on a New Albany class study guess, is that it is four individuals who were laboring within the Catholic Church, each speaking out at their appointed time. rcb

The return of our Lord is represented by the angel coming down from heaven at the close
of the sixth trumpet period (Rev. 10:1) and setting his foot upon (assuming control of) the
land and sea (classes) — the organized, civilized, stable elements and the restless, lawless,
communistic, and anarchistic phases, respectively. The latter’s being under his right foot
may indicate his use of this group as his “great army.” (Joel 2:11) This scene recalls Dan.
12:1, where Michael stands up in another picture of this. This event is followed almost
immediately, in 1878, by the close of the 360-year “chronos” — translated “time” in Rev.
10:6 Ludlow Loomis

In R1094:2 Br. Russell mentions four reformers (not necessarily as an application of this text) as being: Knox, Melanchthon, Zwingli, Calvin. mhf.com

hour=15 days
day =1 year
month=30 years
year=360 years
slay= consecrate
third=that went over to protestantism
men=christians

The true application of
Rev. 9:15 requires exactly 391 years and 15 days as the period of the prophecy's fulfillment. PSL Johnson PT1940

To slay – Not torment merely, but death, political death. CTR HG77:6


Euphrates – The people supporting the system of Babylon. Q720:4

Rev. 9:16 Two hundred thousand thousand – 200 million. - OBSERVATION: This was the population of Christendom around the time of the French Revolution. mhf.com

This indicates that 200,000,000 would be involved in Bible study in the years from 1799 til 1874 when our Lord Jesus returned. Bro. Bob Jones "The Revelation Decoded and Explained"

Rev. 9:17 "horses" are doctrines. "breastplate" of  "fire...brimstone" = destructive to the Papacy. "Jacinth" is hard, protective and beautiful - the Bible Truth.  "heads of lions" meaning spoke with authority as the "mouth" [or "mouthpieces"
I Pet 4:11] of God. rcb

Rev. 9:17 alternative: this refers to the eternal torment doctrine threatened by the adherents of protestantism.
Bob Jones "The Revelation Decoded and Explained"

Rev. 9:18
Many Catholic converts resulted from this, "killed" by the clear arguments of Scripture. rcb
 
Rev. 9:19 The serpent tail inflicted harm, but the lion head brought death. Direct confrontation with the head was soon considered by antagonists to be inadvisable and to be
avoided at all cost.
The tail of a horse usually contains numerous strands of long, somewhat wiry hair.
The tails in the vision were thicker than normal, resembling a snake with its head presumably at the bottom end of the tail. A free translation of this portion of the text
might be rendered in two ways: (a) Each horse had one serpent tail; therefore, the several horses had several tails (one apiece). Or (b) each horse had a cluster of snakes for
a tail; therefore, the several horses had several (multi-serpent) tails. The last interpretation is contextually superior.
240 Seven Seals and Seven Trumpets
The lion head of the horse represents early Reformation doctrine, such as that proclaimed by Luther and his contemporary associates.22 The work began as a loud protest against religious tyranny in doctrine and practice. But as time
progressed—symbolized by the hind or latter part of the horse with its tail—a notable
change took place: That which before had been a single wide breach in the world of
Catholicism now became splintered into several other denominational sects, each with
its own head or spokesman. The lionlike roar and teeth of the one head of each horse
were supplanted by the sinister quietness and the softer hissing tongues of a multitudinous serpent-headed tail. The lion head of each horse, though an exceedingly dreadful
antagonist, was easier to identify and confront face to face than the less outspoken—but more numerous—subtle, evasive, and nonetheless deadly foes later to arise.
Thus Papacy viewed the horse-doctrines under the sixth trumpet.
In this light Papacy has, from time to time, surveyed the progress and the effect of
the Reformation. Frank Shallieu "The Keys of Revelation"

Rev. 9:20-21 "the rest of the men" = those spiritual leaders remaining faithful to the papacy

6th Bowl of Wrath

Rev. 16:12 And the sixth poured out the bowl of himself on the river the great Euphrates; and was dried up the water of it, so that might be prepared the way of the kings of those from risings of a sun.

13 And I saw out of the mouth of the dragon and out of the mouth of the wild-beast and out of the mouth of the false prophet spirits three unclean as frogs;

14 (they are for spirits of demons working signs;) which go forth to the kings of the habitable whole, to gather together them for the war of the day of that of the great of the God of the almighty.

15 (Lo, I come as a thief; blessed the one watching, and keeping the garments of himself, so that not naked he may walk, and they may see the shame of him.) 

16 And he gathered together them into the place that being called in Hebrew Armageddon.



Then came the sixth “bowl” early in this century, which contained much less of controversial writings than the previous five had done. In fact, its title – “The New Creation” – is well in keeping with verse 12 – “that the way of the kings of the east might be prepared”; its purpose was to instruct the true church (kings of the east) in every good word and work. It was the “law,” the better way, to every one who is “of the truth.” And any one who knows and faithfully abides by the teachings of Volume Six can be assured of the best of present possibilities – “a good and honest heart.”

No. 351 "In Memoriam" Epiphany Bible Students


Another match between trumpets and bowls with the focus on the river Euphrates. rcb
 

Euphrates – The people supporting the system of Babylon. Q720:4


Continuing with our view that the 7 bowls or bowls of wrath are the Studies in the Scriptures series by Pastor C.T. Russell, it is a beautiful comparison here since volume 6 "The New Creation" was specifically designed to help the footstep followers of the feet class, those at the end of the Gospel age, to become actual kings and priests, so this book was so "
that the way might be prepared, of the kings who were from the rising of the sun"=the gradual revealing of the sun of righteousness at His second advent. After this book was published, public support for papacy lessened over time, drying up her symbolic Euphrates river of followers and subsequent revenues. rcb

Rev. 16:13-14

"Dragon"=civil power of Rome

The dragon – Civil government, especially that which once constituted civil Rome. R510:4; OV271:4

"Beast"=a mixture of religion with state = Roman Catholic Church

The beast – Papacy. R510:4

"False Prophet" = united protestantism.

Three – The harmonious teaching in which these can all unite is the dogmas of "the divine right of kings," "the authority of the clergy," and the claim that mankind is bound to submit to these and be controlled by them. R510:4[R510:4]

[and "divine right of aristocracy"]


Rev. 16:14
The spirits of devils – Doctrines of devils--the devil's theory relative to present evil governments. R510:5[R510:9]

The spirit of revolution and anarchism in the world is generating a boiling, seething, condition of affairs. Q769:3

Working miracles – Working signs. R510:5

Spiritualism has not yet reached the climax of its power. Its powers are to increase wonderfully. R266:4

Unto the kings – Not only kings, but princes, generals, also those termed financial kings and merchant princes, and the great one among religious teachers. R510:6

To gather them – The croaking of the frog spirits, or doctrines, will gather the kings and princes, financial, political, religious and industrial into one great army. OV274:6; SM235:3

Ecclesiastical kings and princes will be gathered in solid phalanx--Protestant and Catholic. Political kings, financial kings and merchant princes will join the same side. OV274:4; SM233:3

The nations of the earth are already gathered together, associated by the modern methods of communication--cables, wireless telegraphs, railways and steamship lines. Q769:3

The gathering of the armies is plainly visible from the standpoint of God's Word. B101

They do not realize, however, that they are coming to Armageddon. OV274:4

To the battle – The general conflict between priest and people, rulers and ruled, capital and labor. R377:6

Organized capital on the one hand and organized labor on the other are the two forces arrayed against each other in deadly conflict. Q849:T

In proportion as men have aided error and wrong, they have been battling against the new Ruler; and in proportion as their tongues, pens and hands were used to support the right and truth on any subject, they have been fighting on the Lord's side. B141

Prophecy requires an evidently larger number of wealthy Hebrews to be in Israel before the Armageddon crisis. "Jacob's trouble" in the Holy Land will come at the very close of Armageddon. OV276:5; SM239:2

This battle is the seventh plague, and is a result of the six plagues which precede it. R377:3

To war, the conflict between right and wrong. R510:6

The Millennium is preceded by the most terrible judgments on the nations; but, in consequence of these judgments, the people are turned to a pure worship. HG18:5

Typified by Gideon's battle. NS240:6

Rev. 16:15 Our Lord's thief like presence promised to be  upcoming = 1874 "keep his garments" = keeping faith in Jesus, our robe of righteousness. rcb

Rev. 16:16 God will be represented by the great Messiah. He will be on the side of the masses. "At that time shall Michael stand up"--assume authority. (Dan. 12:1) SM236:3

Gathered them together – The turmoil of speech and the conflict between classes are hurrying us toward the vortex of the great Armageddon. R5448:6

Warring political factions, militant suffragettes, socialists, nihilists, anarchists, labor organizations, capitalistic combinations, the ecclesiastical system, all in opposition to each and all; are rushing headlong to Armageddon. Q769:2

Armageddon – Symbolizing the great controversy between truth and error, right and wrong, God and mammon. Dii

Armageddon means mount of destruction; and this describes what will be the result of their doctrine. R510:6; Dii, xiii; OV268:2; 275:2; Q769:2; SM236:3

The Scriptures abound with allusions to Armageddon. Our Lord calls it "great tribulation." (Matt. 24:21); Daniel describes it as "a time of trouble." (Dan. 12:1) OV269:2

V. 16 "Armageddon" see HERE for MORE CTR comments:
6th PARABLE

Pearl of Great Price

Matt 13:45 Again, the kingdom of the heavens is, like, unto, a merchant, seeking beautiful pearls,-

46 and, finding one very precious pearl, departing, he at once sold all things, whatsoever he had, and bought it.

THE PEARL OF GREAT VALUE

Pearls were much more in vogue in ancient times than now. Pearl buyers traded in these gems and carried them to the market, where they were highly estimated. The parable represents one of these pearl merchants as coming across the finest pearl he had ever seen. He considered it so priceless that he was quite rejoiced to sell or trade all of his other pearls and property that he might become the owner of that pearl.

This parable represents the Gospel offer of a share with Christ in his Kingdom as being superior to all other propositions of the world. The honor of the world, of name and fame, position and wealth, are indeed desirable; as the Scriptures say, "A good name is rather to be chosen than great riches"; but when our eyes behold "the pearl of great price," the Kingdom offer of joint-heirship with our Lord Jesus in his heavenly glory and the association with him in his work of blessing all the families of the earth, we realize that this is a priceless thing, worth more by far than all the honors and dignities and pleasures of the world. Those worthy to buy this pearl will gladly exchange all earthly things therefor – even their good name, and this will be necessary, as the Master forewarned them, saying, "they shall say all manner of evil against you falsely for my sake; rejoice and be exceeding glad, for great is your reward in heaven, for so persecuted they the prophets who were before you." [R4637 : page 205] (Matthew 5:11,12). He that is not willing to have the Kingdom at such a cost is not worthy of the Kingdom. The Apostle has said, "Through much tribulation must we enter the Kingdom" (Acts 14:22); and only those who willingly endure such tribulations for righteousness' sake – for the sake of the truth, in obedience to the Heavenly calling – are overcomers. And only to the "overcomers" has the Lord given "the exceeding great and precious promises." "To him that overcometh will I grant to sit with me in my throne." – Rev. 3:21.

Pearl= the Kingdom offer of joint-heirship
R4636

Again – This parable illustrates the process by which his Kingdom is obtainable. R4535:6

Seeking – Seeking imperishable values of not frittering away life and its opportunities; seeking for the best things, and most valuable things, temporal or spiritual. NS514:2

Goodly pearls – In ancient times the pearl occupied the chief place among the jewels of personal adornment. NS511:1

Those qualities and rewards, even of an earthly kind, which would be enduring. NS514:5

All the other pearls--of being a great doctor, a great artist, a great musician, a model house-keeper, or something else--are trifling and insignificant in comparison with this great Pearl. Q428:4; SM681:2


Luther's "Justification By Faith" keynote doctrine of the reformation. rcb





7th Seal

Rev. 8:1 And when he opened the seal the seventh, was silence in the heaven about half an hour.

2 And I saw the seven messengers which, before God, do stand; and there were given unto them seven trumpets.

3 And, another messenger, came, and took his stand at the altar, having a censer of gold: and there was given unto him much incense, that he might give it unto the prayers of all the saints, upon the altar of gold that is before the throne.

4 And the smoke of the incense went up, with the prayers of the saints, out of the hand of the messenger before God.

5 
 And the messenger at once took the censer, and filled it from the fire of the altar, and cast unto the earth; and there came to be thunderings, and voices, and lightnings, and an earthquake.


TBA:
CTR commentary here...


Here we can commend the remarks that form the conclusion of bro. Ludlow Loomis in his "Notes on Revelation"

"Chapters 2 and 3, in the messages to the seven successive stages of the church, Chapters 6 -
8:1, the opening of the seals, and the seven trumpets in Chapters 8 - 11 show the early
church and the falling away and eventually the destruction of the old order and
establishment of the everlasting kingdom of righteousness.
The falling away and destruction of the old order are likewise elaborated in chapters 12 - 20.
Chapters 20 - 22 show the establishment of the kingdom of righteousness. Thus, though
most of its visions deal with the period of the Gospel age followed by the Millennium, there
is a similarity of contrast to the whole Bible narrative which starts with creation, as expressed
in A56:2, showing the fall of man, which follows the account of his creation in perfection
in the first three chapters of Genesis, and the restoration to everlasting righteousness and
life in the last three chapters of the Bible, which are, of course, the last three chapters of
Revelation itself.

A56: This we do find: One plan, spirit, aim and purpose pervades the entire book. Its
opening pages record the creation and fall of man; its closing pages tell of man’s recovery
from that fall; and its intervening pages show the successive steps of the plan of God for
the accomplishment of this purpose. The harmony, yet contrast, of the first three and the
last three chapters of the Bible is striking. The one describes the first creation, the other the
renewed or restored creation, with sin and its penal-curse removed; the one shows Satan
and evil entering the world to deceive and destroy, the other shows his work undone, the
destroyed ones restored, evil extinguished and Satan destroyed; the one shows the
dominion lost by Adam, the other shows it restored and forever established by Christ, and
God’s will done in earth as in heaven; the one shows sin the producing cause of
degradation, shame and death, the other shows the reward of righteousness to be glory,
honor and life.

The importance of this book is increasing as we approach the end of the harvest period. The
signs of approaching fulfilment of its closing features — the siftings among the Lord’s
followers, many of whom are off guard while drinking of the water of truth (Cf. Judges 7:4-
7; the approach of a semblance of peace among the Gentiles (Jer. 6:14; 1 Thes. 5:3) and soon
perhaps even in Israel too (Ezekiel 38:8, 11); Yet the unrest among the Peoples and the
approaching union of churches (Rev. 13:15-17) — alert the watchers, although some would
prefer to close their eyes and ears to these things and write them off as fulfilled or perhaps
put them into the indefinite future.
Ludlow Loomis in his "Notes on Revelation"



7th Stage

Laodicea

1874-

star members
  1. Charles T. Russell
  2. Paul S.L. Johnson
Rev. 3:14 And, unto the messenger of the assembly, in Laodicea, write:-These things, saith the Amen, the faithful and true witness the beginning of the creation of God:

15 I know thy works;-that neither, cold, art thou, nor hot: I would that, cold, thou hadst been, or hot.

16 Thus, because, lukewarm, thou art, and neither hot nor cold, I am about to vomit thee out of my mouth.

 17 Because thou sayest, Rich, am I, and have become enriched, and, of nothing, have I need, and knowest not that, thou, art the wretched one, and pitiable, and destitute, and blind, and naked,

18 I counsel thee to buy of me, gold refined by fire, that thou mayest become rich,-and white raiment, that thou mayest array thyself, and, the shame of thy nakedness, may not be made manifest,-and eye-salve, to anoint thine eyes, that thou mayest see.

19 I, as many as I tenderly love, I convict and put under discipline: be zealous, therefore, and repent.

20 Lo! I am standing at the door, and knocking; if anyone shall hearken unto my voice, and open the door, I will come in unto him, and will sup with him, and, he, with, me.

21 He that overcometh, I will give, unto him, to take his seat with me in my throne, as, I also, overcame, and took my seat with my Father in his throne.

 22 He that hath an ear, let him hear what, the Spirit, is saying unto the assemblies.

And unto the angel – The appropriate message for each appropriate time or epoch in the Church's experience would be sent by the Lord through a particular star or messenger whom he would particularly commission as his representative. R3570:4, 2826:6

The number of Scriptures which speak of the Gospel Church after being cast off from God's favor, and of her rapid decline and fall are somewhat wonderful. In Rev. 3:14 to 21, the whole picture is vividly presented. The Lord is addressing the last phase of the Church, the seventh. [We in common, with nearly all expositors of the Apocalypse, understand the seven Churches here addressed to represent seven phases or conditions of the entire nominal Church, from the days of the apostles to the end of the Gospel age, in the order mentioned.] To this seventh Church, Jesus says: "I know thy works," [the works are greater far than the faith] "that thou art neither cold nor hot; so, then, because thou art lukewarm I will spew thee out of My mouth." What a description this is of the present condition of her, whom God calls "Babylon" – confusion – mixture – lukewarm.

Babylon says she is "rich, increased in goods and has need of nothing;" that she is in a more prosperous condition than ever before, and she boasts of fine churches, high steeples, eloquent preachers, wealthy members, splendid music, large salaries and worldly popularity, and knows not that she is "poor and miserable and blind," (stumbling over present truths) and remembers not that her worldly popularity is an evidence of her disfavor with the Bridegroom. "For the friendship of the world is enmity against God." She is therefore given up, as was the fleshly house – she is "spewed out of His mouth." She has been His mouthpiece, and through her He has spoken to the world, but it shall be so no longer. "The voice of the Bridegroom and the Bride shall be heard no more at all in thee." Rev. 18:23... R177:1

The church in the end of the Gospel age. R4870:2, 5651:5

This message is sent particularly to those who profess Christ's name, but deny the truth which he himself here presents. R5993:5

"the beginning of the creation of God"- Jehovah's Logos, his Only Begotten Son. R2408:5, 3861:5

The one first created. HG272:3

He was both the first created and the first or highest in rank of the angels. As Archangel, he was pre-eminent over all and the life-giver to "all creation." R1063:6*, 1060:4, 417:6, 164:2

He has been the agent of Jehovah in all that has since been done. R369:5

The only being directly created by Jehovah. R5748:1, 1060:4

The Lord became the "only begotten son of God" at the time of his creation. Q746:3

THE CONGREGATION IN LAODICEA – (Laodicea meaning "justice for the people," in allusion to the rebellion of the masses against the classes, which speedily leads up to Armageddon). This period began technically in 1874, still continues, and contained only two "stars" – Brother Russell and Brother Johnson, the same being also the seventh and eighth principal men of Micah 5:5.
J Hoefle "The Seven Stars"
7th Trumpet

Rev. 10:7 but, in the days of the sounding of the seventh messenger, as soon as he is about to blow his trumpet, then shall have been completed the sacred secret of God as he told the good-news unto his own servants the prophets.

Rev. 11:15 And the seventh messenger sounded, and were voices great in the heaven, saying: Became the kingdom of the world, of the Lord of us and of the Anointed of him, and he will reign for the age of the ages.

16 And the twenty-four elders those in presence of the God sitting on the thrones of themselves, fell on the faces of themselves, and worshipped the God,

17 saying: We give thanks to thee, O Lord the God the almighty, the one existing and who was, because thou hast taken the power of thee the great, and reigned.

18 And the nations were angry, and came the wrath of thee, and the season of the dead ones, to be judged and to give the reward to the bond-servants of thee the prophets and to the holy ones and to those fearing the name of thee the small ones and the great ones, and to destroy those destroying the earth.

19 And was opened the temple of the God in the heaven, and was seen the ark of the covenant of the Lord in the temple of him; and were lightnings and voices and thunders and an earthquake and hail great.

The seventh trumpet covers the entire period of the Millennial reign of Christ, as indicated by the events which are to transpire under it. (Rev. 11:15, 18) B149

Be finished – When the Church is exalted, the mystery both of the Church and God's plan will be finished. R194:4; A87

Mystery is used in the same sense as the word church. Thus the true and false churches are called, "The mystery of God," and "The mystery of iniquity." (Col. 1:27; 2 Thes. 2:7) R368:6

Not until the days of the voice or sounding of the seventh trumpet--in the end or close of this Gospel age and the dawn of the Millennial age. R4452:5, 368:3; CR361:4; OV6:T

Not until the last seal was broken, did the scroll fly wide open, permitting the "mystery of God" to be fully disclosed. (Rev. 5:1) R2209:1, 2156:4

The due time for revealing to the Church the divine plan respecting its participation with Christ in the blessing of all the families of the earth--"meat in due season." R2490:2

This is the very time of the completion of the bride. Now there is a little flock of 144,000 as of September 16, 1916. rcb

For our Pastor it was only six weeks later he passed beyond the veil October 31, 1916, "just as he is about to blow - then - shall have been completed - what we think refers to the church as the mystery finally revealed. rcb
7th Bowl of Wrath

Rev. 16:17 And the seventh poured out the bowl of himself on the air; and came forth a voice great from the temple of the heaven, from the throne, saying: It has been done.

18 And were lightnings and voices and thunders, and an earthquake was great, such not was from of which the men were on the earth, so great an earthquake so great.

19 And was the city the great into three parts, and the cities of the nations feel; and Babylon the great was remembered before the God, to give to her the cup of the wine of the wrath of the anger of himself;

20 and every island fled away, and mountains not were found,

21 and hail great as if weighing a talent comes down out of the heaven on the men; and blasphemed the men the God on account of the plague of the hail, because great is the plague of her exceedingly.


Rev. 17:1
And came one of the seven messengers of those having the seven bowls, and spoke with me, saying: Come hither, I will show to thee the judgment of the harlot the great, of that sitting on the waters the many;

2 with whom committed fornication the kings of the earth, and were made drunk those inhabiting the earth with the wine of the fornication of her.

3 And he carried away me into a desert in spirit; and I saw a woman sitting on a wild beast scarlet, being full of names of blasphemy, having heads seven and horns ten.

4 And the woman was having clothed purple and scarlet, and having been gilded with gold and a stone precious and pearls having golden a cup in the hand of herself being full of abomination, and the uncleannesses of the fornication of herself,

5 and on the forehead of herself a name having been written: Mystery: Babylon the great, the mother of the harlots and of the abominations of the earth.


6 And I saw the woman drunken with the blood of the holy ones, and with the blood of the witnesses of Jesus. And I wondered, having seen her a wonder great. [Wilson's Emphatic Diaglott]

 
The seventh vial – titled “The Finished Mystery” – did not appear until 1917; and, as Brother Johnson so aptly stated, it appeared in a vile condition. It had been produced by uncleansed Levites – a “rush” production, at the urging of That Evil Servant in this haste to “eat and drink with the drunken” (Levites drunken with error). However, as the seventh “bowl” (its controversial features), there was not too much fault to be found with it, the reason for this being that the “bowl” portions of “The Finished Mystery” were almost completely paraphrase or exact quotation from the Star Member. It was the injection of their own ideas into what should have been a priestly production that brought those uncleansed Levites eventually to Atlanta Federal Penitentiary. They had run ahead of the Lord to publish the seventh vial; had published it in a vile condition; and the Lord rewarded them “according to their works” – by reducing them to durance vile (prison). In fact, the expression in verse 6 regarding Vol. 3 is also emphatically pertinent here: “Thou gavest them also blood to drink (revulsive error); they deserve it.” (Rev. 16:6, Dia.)

It would seem in order here to declare that the “seventh bowl” not only plagued Big Babylon, but is also produced a severe contagion right in the backyard of those who had Published it: ecclesias in many quarters were split right down the middle over the book; it was made a test of fellowship near and far, It was not enough just to keep quiet if you did not believe all of it; you must openly espouse it. At that time we ourselves were ejected from the colporteur work because we did not offer it for sale, although we were offering the other six volumes to the public.

No. 351 "In Memoriam" Epiphany Bible Students




7th PARABLE

The Drag Net

Matt 13:47 Again, the kingdom of the heavens is like unto, a large drag-net, cast into the sea and gathering of every kind,-

48 
 which, when it was filled, they dragged up on the beach, and, sitting down, collected the good into vessels, but, the worthless, forth they cast.

49 
 So, will it be in the conclusion of the age: The messengers will come forth, and separate the wicked from among the righteous;

50 
 and will cast them into the furnace of fire: there, will be wailing and gnashing of teeth.

This parable is applicable to the close of the Gospel age. C213

Is like unto – Not like a net; but the embryo Kingdom resembles a fishing experience with a net. R5048:2

A net – The Gospel message. R4637:1

Representing the nominal church of this present time. HG438:6

That was cast – First cast at Pentecost, and from then to the present harvest time it has been gathering in all sorts of fish, together constituting the great nominal Gospel church. R1716:1, 920:1

Into the sea – The world. C214

And gathered – "I will make you fishers of men." (Matt. 4:19)
C214; R5555:2

Of every kind – Real Christians, half-deceived and deluded Christians, and multitudes of hypocrites.
C214

They – The fishermen, the Lord's people.
C214; R5555:1

Drew to shore – Withdrew the invitation to a place in the Kingdom.
C214

Sat down – Not to dive again into the sea, either with net or hook and line, to gather more fish. R920:2

And gathered – Separated, divided.
C214; D600

"Come out of her, my people." (Rev. 18:4) D601

The catching and the sorting are two parts of the one grand work of making ready a people prepared for the Lord, corresponding to the works of the sower and the reaper.
R1716:4

Into vessels – The special work of harvest is the gathering of the good fish into safety, rather than to catch more fish.
R1716:4

Cast the bad away – As unsuitable for a place in the Kingdom.
C214; R5555:1, 2, 4637:1

Corresponds with the tares of Matt. 13:30. The unsuitable fish in the net are all church members. The unprofessing world are not represented in the parable at all. R5048:5

End of the world – The end of this age, a sifting and separating time. R4637:1;
C214

"The harvest is the end of the age." (Matt. 13:39)
C214

When the Lord shall have gathered the foreordained number of the elect Church. R5048:4

The wicked – But some of the true children of God will also be rejected and get into the wailing and gnashing of teeth condition because they have assimilated with the worldly-minded. R920:5 [R1000]

Furnace of fire – The great time of trouble. R5048:5[R5048:5], 4637:1[4637:1]

Gnashing of teeth – "Gnawing their tongues in pain." (Rev. 16:10) R920:5 [R1000]

Symbolically expressing the vexation and anger of those in whom the truth only awakens a spirit of opposition and hatred. R920:4 [R1000]

See comments on Matt. 13:42
Rev. 8:8 And, the voice which I had heard out of heaven, I again heard talking with me; and saying-Go take the opened scroll, that is in the hand of the messenger who is standing upon the sea and upon the land.

9 And I went away unto the messenger, asking him to give me the little scroll; and he saith unto me- Take it, and eat it up; and it shall embitter thy belly, but, in thy mouth, shall be sweet as honey.

10 And I took the little scroll out of the hand of the messenger, and did eat it up; and it was, in my mouth, as honey, sweet, and, when I had eaten it, embittered was my belly.

11 And they say unto me-It behoveth thee again to prophesy against peoples and nations and tongues, and many kings.



More on 7 bowls of wrath

"A VOICE OUT OF THE TEMPLE"

The caption for this treatise is taken from Rev. 16:1, the real thought of which would be better expressed by “A voice out of the Tabernacle.” To substantiate this conclusion it becomes necessary first of all to offer an analysis of Brother Russell’s Stewardship Doctrine, which we believe to be:

A correct understanding of the Atonement as portrayed in Leviticus 16, the central teaching of which is Restitution.

It should be noted that those Star Members who received special stewardship doctrines received them early in their ministry; quite often those doctrines were the cause of their leaving the religious group with whom they had been associated; and it was the teaching that provided stimulus throughout their entire ministry. For instance, Martin Luther was motivated by Romans 5:1 to break with the Catholic Church, because this text was a direct contradiction of the Catholic belief in justification by works, as opposed to St. Paul’s clear statement that it is justification by faith that brings “peace with God.” Luther’s primary objection, of course, was the sale of indulgences, the elimination of which he believed would at least start a cleansing of the Roman system; but it soon became clear to him – after his expulsion from that Church – that it was simply a surface malady, fed and encouraged by justification by works. Thus, his “justification by faith” almost automatically and very quickly be­came the antithesis of indulgences and their underlying evils.

While the doctrine of Restitution was not directly responsible for Bro. Russell’s leaving his “orthodox” surroundings, it was indeed indirectly responsible for his do­ing so. His very vitals rebelled at the teaching of eternal torment for the unsaved world; and this revulsion – much the same as Luther’s experiences with indulgences in turn drove him toward the proper explanation, which he received when the Atonement ­Day ritual was made clear to him in type and antitype. That the doctrine of Restitu­tion sparked Brother Russell’s entire ministry after receiving this Truth surely none will dispute. It is probable he never delivered a public discourse thereafter in which Restitution did not have a large and prominent place. And those who witnessed the Photo Drama will recall the oft–repeated expressions: “India needs Restitution; China needs Restitution,” etc., etc. We know, too, that his favorite Scripture was John 3:16, 17, the mainspring of which is also Restitution – “For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life.” And early in his ministry he urged the Pilgrims and the Bethel speakers to stress Restitution in their public discourses, as he him­self also did.

To avoid argument, it should be here stated that Brother Russell taught all the stewardship doctrines of the past, in addition to Restitution, although he had to remove many a rough spot from those doctrines – taints, impurities and distortions that had been attached to them by the crown–lost leaders of the past. When the Harvest arrived, the time also arrived to restore “the faith once delivered to the Saints” (Jude 3), so that the “Harp of God” would once more be attuned to its pristine harmonious melody. This Brother Russell accomplished with all the skill of the master artisan!

OCTOBER 1, 1968
NO. 160: "A VOICE OUT OF THE TEMPLE"
by Epiphany Bible Students


8th PARABLE

The Householder

Matt 13:51 Have ye understood all these things? They say unto him, Yea!

52 
 And, he, said unto them-Wherefore, every scribe, discipled unto the kingdom of the heavens, is like unto a householder, who putteth forth out of his treasure, things new and old.